Winter traction devices are essential for safe driving on snow and ice. We researched and compared the top options using manufacturer specifications, published industry standards, and aggregated owner feedback. Our evaluation focuses on performance, durability, ease of use, and safety to help you choose the right device for your vehicle and conditions.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
SCC Super Z6 SZ143 Best Overall Compatible with passenger cars and SUVs; fits tires up to P245/75R16 |
9.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Peerless Auto-Trac 0232155 Best Value Fits most passenger cars and minivans; tire size up to P235/75R15 |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Security Chain Company SZ143 Super Z6 Top Rated Fits tires from P195/65R15 to P255/70R16 |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Thule CG-9 410 Premium Pick Compatible with SUVs and light trucks; tire sizes up to 285/70R17 |
8.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Spikes Spiders SP12-222 Easy Install Fits most passenger cars and SUVs; tire size up to P235/70R16 |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Konig XG-12 Pro Chain Alternative Fits passenger cars and SUVs; tire sizes from 195/65R15 to 245/70R16 |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Peerless Chain 0152100 Auto-Trac Budget Cable Fits most passenger cars; tire size up to P195/70R14 |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. SCC Super Z6 SZ143: Best Overall
The SCC Super Z6 SZ143 stands out for its aggressive Z6 alloy pattern that bites into ice and hard-packed snow. Based on owner feedback, it provides confident handling on steep grades and unplowed roads. The quick-fit tensioner system simplifies installation, though some users report it requires practice to get tight. In our evaluation, the durability of the alloy links is a key advantage over cable-style devices, but the added weight and noise on dry pavement are tradeoffs.
This device is ideal for drivers who frequently encounter severe winter conditions and need maximum traction. However, if you primarily drive on plowed roads with occasional ice patches, a lighter cable device may be more convenient. Skip the Super Z6 if you have limited trunk space or dislike the clatter on clear roads.
- Z6 alloy construction provides aggressive traction on ice and packed snow.
- Quick-fit tensioner allows installation without moving the vehicle.
- Includes storage bag and spare links for field repairs.
Pros: Excellent traction in deep snow and ice.; Durable alloy links resist wear.
Cons: Can be noisy on clear pavement.; Not recommended for low-profile tires.
2. Peerless Auto-Trac 0232155: Best Value
The Peerless Auto-Trac 0232155 offers a solid balance of cost and capability. Its twist-link cable system provides adequate grip on icy roads and moderate snow, and the self-tightening cam reduces the need for manual adjustments. Owner feedback indicates that installation is straightforward but can be fiddly in cold conditions. The zinc plating helps prevent rust, but some users report cable fraying after several seasons of use.
This is a great choice for budget-conscious drivers who need occasional traction in light to moderate winter conditions. However, if you live in an area with heavy snowfall or frequent ice storms, consider a chain-based model for better durability and bite. Skip the Auto-Trac if you require maximum traction for off-road or mountain driving.
- Twist-link cable design for easy installation and removal.
- Self-tightening cam mechanism adjusts tension automatically.
- Corrosion-resistant zinc plating extends service life.
Pros: Affordable price point with good winter traction.; Lightweight and easy to store.
Cons: Cables can stretch over time, requiring retightening.; Less effective in deep snow than chain-style devices.
3. Security Chain Company SZ143 Super Z6: Top Rated
The Security Chain Company SZ143 Super Z6 is a close variant of the SCC Super Z6, offering the same Z6 link pattern for aggressive traction. Owner reviews consistently praise its performance on icy hills and unplowed roads. The quick-fit tensioner with color indicators simplifies tightening, though some users note that achieving proper tension requires practice. In our evaluation, the durability of the alloy links is a strong point, but the weight and noise on dry pavement are drawbacks.
This device is best for drivers who prioritize traction above all else and are willing to tolerate added weight and noise. It is not ideal for those who need a device for occasional use on mostly plowed roads, as lighter cable options would be more convenient. Skip this if your vehicle has limited clearance or you dislike the installation process.
- Z6 alloy links provide six points of contact per link for superior grip.
- Quick-fit tensioner with color-coded adjustment indicators.
- Meets SAE Class S clearance requirements for passenger vehicles.
Pros: Excellent grip on ice and hard-packed snow.; Durable construction with replaceable cross links.
Cons: Heavier than cable-style devices.; Installation can be challenging on tight wheel wells.
4. Thule CG-9 410: Premium Pick
The Thule CG-9 410 is a premium traction device designed for demanding conditions. Its hardened steel chains with tungsten carbide studs provide outstanding grip on ice, as confirmed by owner feedback from mountain drivers. The ratchet tensioning system is easier to use than traditional cam mechanisms, though the overall weight makes installation a two-person job for some. In our evaluation, the durability is top-tier, but the high price limits its value for occasional users.
This device is best for serious winter drivers in extreme climates who need the highest level of traction and are willing to invest. Skip the CG-9 if you drive on mostly plowed roads or have a limited budget, as more affordable options provide sufficient performance for lighter conditions.
- Hardened steel chain links with tungsten carbide studs for ice grip.
- Quick-mount system with self-tensioning ratchet.
- Includes heavy-duty storage bag and installation gloves.
Pros: Exceptional ice traction due to carbide studs.; Robust construction for heavy use.
Cons: Very expensive compared to other options.; Heavy and bulky to store and install.
5. Spikes Spiders SP12-222: Easy Install
The Spikes Spiders SP12-222 uses a strap-based system that wraps around the tire, making it one of the easiest traction devices to install. Owner feedback highlights the convenience, especially for those who dislike wrestling with chains. However, the rubber and metal spikes provide only moderate grip on ice and deep snow, and some users report strap slippage after extended use. In our evaluation, the durability is adequate for occasional use, but the traction is not on par with chain devices.
This device is ideal for drivers who want a quick, no-fuss solution for light snow and ice, or for those with vehicles that have minimal wheel well clearance. Skip the Spikes Spiders if you frequently drive in heavy snow or on icy mountain roads, as a chain-based device will offer much better traction and reliability.
- Tire-mounted design with adjustable tension straps.
- No need to move the vehicle for installation.
- Lightweight and compact for easy storage.
Pros: Very easy to install and remove.; Compatible with vehicles with limited clearance.
Cons: Less traction than chain-style devices on ice.; Straps can loosen over time and require retightening.
6. Konig XG-12 Pro: Chain Alternative
The Konig XG-12 Pro combines twisted steel cables with cross links to offer a middle ground between cables and chains. Owner reviews report good traction on ice and packed snow, with less noise than traditional chains. The self-tensioning cam with an audible click helps achieve proper fit, though some users find the installation fiddly. In our evaluation, the durability is solid for moderate use, but the hybrid design may not hold up as well as full chains under extreme conditions.
This device is a good choice for drivers who want improved traction over standard cables without the full weight and noise of chains. However, if you encounter deep snow or severe ice regularly, a dedicated chain device would be more reliable. Skip the XG-12 Pro if you need a device for heavy commercial use or extreme mountain driving.
- Hybrid cable-chain design with twisted steel cables and cross links.
- Self-tensioning cam with audible click for proper tightness.
- Corrosion-resistant coating for longevity.
Pros: Better ice traction than cables alone.; Quieter on dry pavement than full chains.
Cons: More expensive than basic cable chains.; Installation can be tricky in tight spaces.
7. Peerless Chain 0152100 Auto-Trac: Budget Cable
The Peerless Chain 0152100 Auto-Trac is a budget-friendly cable chain that provides basic traction for light snow conditions. Owner feedback indicates that it works adequately on slush and light snow but struggles on ice and deep powder. The cam-lock tensioner is simple to use, but the cables are prone to stretching and occasional breakage under stress. In our evaluation, the durability is the weakest point, making it suitable only for occasional, low-speed use.
This device is best for drivers who need a low-cost emergency option for rare snow encounters, such as in regions with mild winters. Skip the Auto-Trac if you face regular winter conditions or require reliable traction for safety, as more robust chain or cable options are worth the extra investment.
- Twisted steel cable design for basic traction.
- Cam-lock tensioner for quick adjustment.
- Lightweight and easy to store.
Pros: Very affordable.; Lightweight and compact.
Cons: Limited traction on ice and deep snow.; Cables can break under heavy load or high speed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need winter traction devices if I have snow tires?
Snow tires significantly improve traction, but they may not be sufficient in areas with chain laws or extreme ice conditions. Traction devices provide additional bite on ice and packed snow, and are often required by law on certain mountain passes. We recommend carrying a set even with snow tires for emergency situations.
How do I choose the right size traction device for my tires?
Check your tire sidewall for the size (e.g., P235/65R17). Most manufacturers provide a fitment chart based on tire dimensions. Ensure the device is compatible with your tire width, aspect ratio, and diameter. Also consider your vehicle’s wheel well clearance, as some devices may not fit with limited space.
Can I drive at highway speeds with traction devices on?
Most traction devices have a maximum speed rating, typically 30-50 mph (48-80 km/h). Exceeding these speeds can damage the device, your tires, or your vehicle. Always follow the manufacturer’s recommendations and remove the devices when roads are clear.
Are cable chains as good as traditional chains?
Cable chains are lighter and easier to install, but they generally provide less traction on ice and deep snow compared to traditional link chains. For moderate winter conditions, cables may suffice, but for severe ice and heavy snow, chain-style devices offer better bite and durability.
How do I maintain and store winter traction devices?
After use, rinse off road salt and dirt, then dry thoroughly to prevent rust. Inspect for damaged links or cables and replace as needed. Store in a dry location, ideally in the provided storage bag, to keep them clean and ready for use.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing specifications, owner feedback, and safety standards, the SCC Super Z6 SZ143 earns our top pick for its exceptional traction on ice and snow, durable alloy construction, and relatively easy installation. For a more affordable option that still provides reliable performance, the Peerless Auto-Trac 0232155 is a strong runner-up, offering good value for moderate winter conditions.
