After researching owner feedback, manufacturer specifications, and industry standards, we compared the top swingarm bags designed for Harley-Davidson Softail models. Swingarm bags offer a sleek, low-profile storage solution without bulky saddlebags. Our evaluation focuses on fitment, weather resistance, mounting security, and real-world durability. Whether you need a compact tool roll or a larger bag for weekend essentials, this guide will help you choose the right one.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Viking Bags Swingarm Bag XL Best Overall 600D polyester, 12x6x5 inches, 1.5 lbs |
9.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Kuryakyn Swingarm Bag Runner Up Ballistic nylon, 11x6x4 inches, 1.2 lbs |
8.9 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Viking Bags Swingarm Bag Small Compact Choice 600D polyester, 9x5x4 inches, 0.9 lbs |
8.5 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Le Pera Swingarm Bag Premium Material Genuine leather, 10x6x4 inches, 1.8 lbs |
8.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Rough Rider Swingarm Bag Budget Pick Nylon, 12x7x5 inches, 1.0 lbs |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Saddlemen Swingarm Bag Heavy Duty PVC tarpaulin, 11x6x5 inches, 2.0 lbs |
7.5 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Biltwell Swingarm Bag Minimalist Cordura nylon, 8x4x3 inches, 0.6 lbs |
7.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Viking Bags Swingarm Bag XL: Best Overall
The Viking Bags Swingarm Bag XL impressed us with its robust 600D polyester construction and thoughtful design. Based on owner feedback, the waterproof inner liner keeps contents dry even in heavy rain. The reflective piping adds a safety element for night riding. Mounting is straightforward with adjustable straps that stay put without scratching the swingarm.
However, riders with aftermarket swingarms or very wide frames should double-check dimensions. The bag is not designed for extreme off-road use, and the zipper can be stiff when new. It’s best for Softail owners who want a reliable, mid-sized bag for daily essentials.
- Fits most Softail models with easy strap mounting
- Waterproof inner liner and reflective piping
- Internal organizer pockets for small items
Pros: Excellent build quality and weather resistance; Secure mounting with anti-slip straps
Cons: May not fit models with very wide swingarms
2. Kuryakyn Swingarm Bag: Runner Up
Kuryakyn’s Swingarm Bag stands out for its user-friendly quick-release buckle system. In our comparison, it scored high for ease of use. The ballistic nylon feels durable, and the padded interior provides peace of mind for fragile items. The included rain cover is a nice touch, though it’s not attached and could be lost.
Some owners reported that the bag can shift slightly on rough roads, so it’s best for casual cruising rather than aggressive riding. It’s a great choice for Softail owners who prioritize quick access and convenience over maximum capacity.
- Quick-release buckle system for easy removal
- Padded interior protects tools and phone
- Includes rain cover for extra weather protection
Pros: Very easy to install and remove; Padded interior adds protection
Cons: Rain cover can be misplaced easily
3. Viking Bags Swingarm Bag Small: Compact Choice
For riders who need minimal storage, the Viking Bags Small Swingarm Bag is a smart pick. Its slim profile tucks neatly against the swingarm without interfering with riding gear. The waterproof zipper and sealed seams offer reliable moisture protection. The removable shoulder strap is a handy bonus.
However, its small size limits usage to essentials like a phone, wallet, and keys. It won’t fit a standard tool roll or a water bottle. It’s ideal for minimalist Softail owners who want a bag that’s barely noticeable.
- Slim profile fits tight spaces
- Waterproof zipper and sealed seams
- Removable shoulder strap for off-bike use
Pros: Compact and unobtrusive; Good value for the price
Cons: Too small for a full-size tool roll
4. Le Pera Swingarm Bag: Premium Material
Le Pera’s swingarm bag is a premium option for those who appreciate traditional materials. The genuine leather and brass hardware give it a classic look that complements vintage-style Softails. In our evaluation, durability is a standout feature; the leather can last for years with proper care.
However, it lacks a waterproof liner, and the magnetic closure is not as secure as zippers. It’s heavier and may not hold up well in constant rain. This bag is best for fair-weather riders who prioritize aesthetics over practicality.
- Handcrafted leather with brass hardware
- Magnetic closure for quick access
- Fits Softail models with narrow swingarms
Pros: Beautiful leather craftsmanship; Very durable and ages well
Cons: Heavier and less weather resistant than synthetic
5. Rough Rider Swingarm Bag: Budget Pick
The Rough Rider Swingarm Bag offers the most storage space for the lowest price. Based on owner feedback, it can hold a weekend’s worth of small items. The nylon material is lightweight and reasonably water-resistant, but not fully waterproof.
Durability is a concern; the Velcro straps can lose grip after repeated use, and the stitching may fray. It’s a decent entry-level option for Softail owners on a budget, but we recommend upgrading the mounting system for security.
- Affordable price point
- Large capacity for tools or clothes
- Adjustable Velcro straps for mounting
Pros: Very spacious for the price; Lightweight
Cons: Velcro straps may loosen over time
6. Saddlemen Swingarm Bag: Heavy Duty
Saddlemen’s Swingarm Bag is built for tough conditions. The PVC tarpaulin material is highly abrasion-resistant and completely waterproof when rolled correctly. It’s a solid choice for riders who encounter harsh weather or rough roads.
However, the bag’s bulk can interfere with leg clearance on some Softail models, and the roll-top closure is inconvenient for frequent access. It’s best for long-distance touring where weather protection is critical, not for daily errands.
- Rugged PVC construction resists abrasion
- Roll-top closure for waterproof seal
- Mounting hardware included
Pros: Very tough and waterproof; Roll-top keeps contents dry
Cons: Bulky and heavy; Difficult to access quickly
7. Biltwell Swingarm Bag: Minimalist
The Biltwell Swingarm Bag is the smallest and lightest option we evaluated. It’s designed for riders who want to carry just a phone and a credit card. The Cordura nylon is durable, but the bag offers no water resistance. Mounting is simple with hook-and-loop straps.
This bag is not suitable for tools or any significant cargo. It’s best for short rides where you need to stash a small item. Safety is a concern as the bag can sag if overloaded. It’s a niche product for those who prioritize minimalism above all else.
- Ultra-compact for minimalists
- Simple hook-and-loop strap mount
- Lightweight and low profile
Pros: Very easy to install and remove; Does not affect bike aesthetics
Cons: Very small capacity; No weather protection
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a swingarm bag fit my Softail model?
Most swingarm bags are designed to fit a range of Softail models, but it’s important to check the dimensions of your swingarm. Measure the width and length of the swingarm area where the bag will sit. Bags with adjustable straps offer more flexibility. For specific models like the Fat Boy or Heritage, consult owner reviews or manufacturer fitment guides.
How do I install a swingarm bag on my Softail?
Installation typically involves wrapping straps around the swingarm and securing them with buckles, Velcro, or clips. Ensure the bag is positioned so it does not interfere with the brake caliper, belt, or chain. Tighten straps firmly to prevent movement. Many bags come with anti-slip padding to protect the swingarm finish.
Are swingarm bags waterproof?
Water resistance varies by brand. Some bags have waterproof inner liners or sealed zippers, while others rely on a rain cover. Materials like PVC tarpaulin are fully waterproof, while nylon and leather are not. If you ride in wet conditions, look for a bag with a waterproof rating or a built-in rain cover.
Can I carry tools in a swingarm bag?
Yes, many swingarm bags are designed to hold tools and a tire repair kit. Check the bag’s capacity and internal organization. For heavy tools, choose a bag with reinforced stitching and secure mounting. Avoid overloading, as it can cause the bag to sag or affect handling.
Will a swingarm bag affect my motorcycle's handling?
A properly installed swingarm bag that is lightweight and securely mounted should not affect handling. However, an overloaded or loose bag can shift weight and cause instability. Always follow the manufacturer’s weight limit and check the bag’s position before riding.
Our Verdict
After thorough research, the Viking Bags Swingarm Bag XL is our top pick for its excellent balance of durability, weather protection, and ease of use. For a more affordable option that still delivers solid performance, the Kuryakyn Swingarm Bag is a strong runner-up with its quick-release convenience.
