After researching manufacturer specifications, industry safety standards, and aggregated owner feedback, we compared the top spare wheels for trailers. Our evaluation focuses on load capacity, tire construction, wheel material, and ease of mounting. Whether you need a spare for a boat trailer, utility trailer, or RV, this guide will help you choose a reliable backup that meets safety requirements and fits your budget.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Taskmaster Premium Trailer Wheel and Tire Combo Best Overall 5-lug, 4.5-inch bolt pattern, 205/75R15, 2200 lbs capacity |
9.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Carlisle Radial Trail HD Trailer Tire and Wheel Top Rated 5-lug, 4.5-inch bolt pattern, ST205/75R15, 2150 lbs capacity |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Kenda Loadstar K579 Trailer Tire and Wheel Best Value 5-lug, 4.5-inch bolt pattern, ST205/75R15, 2150 lbs capacity |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Goodyear Endurance Trailer Tire and Wheel Premium Pick 5-lug, 4.5-inch bolt pattern, ST205/75R15, 2200 lbs capacity |
9.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Taskmaster Specialty Trailer Wheel and Tire Combo Compact Option 4-lug, 4-inch bolt pattern, 5.30-12, 715 lbs capacity |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Wheel Master Trailer Wheel and Tire Combo Budget Pick 5-lug, 4.5-inch bolt pattern, ST205/75D15, 2150 lbs capacity |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Maxxis M8008 ST Trailer Tire and Wheel Durable Choice 5-lug, 4.5-inch bolt pattern, ST205/75R15, 2150 lbs capacity |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Taskmaster Premium Trailer Wheel and Tire Combo: Best Overall
Based on our research of manufacturer specs and owner feedback, the Taskmaster Premium combo stands out for its radial tire construction, which provides superior stability and heat dissipation compared to bias-ply tires. The 2200-pound capacity covers most single-axle utility and boat trailers. The steel rim is powder-coated for corrosion resistance, and the assembly comes pre-mounted for easy installation.
However, this spare is on the heavier side, which might be a consideration if you have limited storage or need to frequently lift it. It is not ideal for those seeking a lightweight aluminum spare for weight savings. Overall, it is a solid, reliable choice for most trailer owners.
- Radial tire construction for better stability and heat dissipation at highway speeds.
- Heavy-duty steel rim with a corrosion-resistant black powder coat finish.
- Includes a pre-mounted tire and wheel assembly, ready to bolt on.
Pros: Excellent highway stability due to radial design.; Rugged steel rim holds up to rough roads.
Cons: Heavier than some aluminum alternatives.
2. Carlisle Radial Trail HD Trailer Tire and Wheel: Top Rated
Our comparison of owner feedback and spec sheets shows that the Carlisle Radial Trail HD is a highly regarded spare, especially for boat and utility trailers. The ST radial tire has reinforced sidewalls to handle the demands of trailer use, and the galvanized steel wheel offers superior corrosion protection. Many owners report long tread life and stable towing.
However, a few owners noted that the tire may require balancing for highway speeds, as some units come slightly out of balance. If you tow frequently at high speeds, you may want to have it balanced before mounting. It remains an excellent choice for those prioritizing durability and rust resistance.
- Special Trailer (ST) radial tire with reinforced sidewalls for heavy loads.
- Galvanized steel wheel for extra rust protection.
- Tread design optimized for long wear and reduced rolling resistance.
Pros: Reinforced sidewalls handle heavy loads well.; Galvanized wheel resists rust better than painted steel.
Cons: Some owners report minor balance issues at high speed.
3. Kenda Loadstar K579 Trailer Tire and Wheel: Best Value
Based on our research of budget-friendly options, the Kenda Loadstar K579 offers a cost-effective spare without sacrificing essential load capacity. The bias-ply construction is adequate for occasional use and lower speeds, and the steel rim is painted to resist rust. Owner feedback indicates it fits well on common utility and boat trailers.
However, bias-ply tires are not as heat-resistant as radials, so this spare is best suited for trailers that are not towed at high speeds for long distances. If you frequently travel on highways, you might want to invest in a radial spare. For occasional use and budget-conscious buyers, this is a practical choice.
- Bias-ply construction for lower cost and adequate load support.
- Steel rim with durable black paint finish.
- Pre-assembled and ready to install.
Pros: Very affordable spare option.; Solid load rating for most small to medium trailers.
Cons: Bias-ply tires generate more heat at highway speeds than radials.
4. Goodyear Endurance Trailer Tire and Wheel: Premium Pick
Our evaluation of premium trailer spares found the Goodyear Endurance to be a top performer in terms of durability and safety. The aramid-reinforced belts provide excellent puncture resistance, and the radial design keeps heat low even at 75 mph. Owner feedback consistently praises its longevity and stability, making it a favorite for RV and heavy boat trailers.
However, the premium comes at a higher cost, which may not be justified for those who only need a spare for occasional short trips. If you tow frequently or over long distances, the investment in a Goodyear Endurance can provide peace of mind. For budget-focused buyers, there are more affordable options that still meet safety standards.
- Advanced radial construction with aramid-reinforced belts for strength.
- Enhanced tread compound for long wear and chip resistance.
- Galvanized steel wheel with a sleek black finish.
Pros: Exceptional durability and puncture resistance.; Smooth ride and low heat buildup at highway speeds.
Cons: Higher price point than many competitors.
5. Taskmaster Specialty Trailer Wheel and Tire Combo: Compact Option
Based on our research of small trailer spares, the Taskmaster Specialty combo is a good fit for jet ski trailers, small utility trailers, and other light loads. The 5.30-12 tire and 715-pound capacity are sufficient for these applications, and the white spoke wheel adds a traditional aesthetic. Owner feedback indicates it mounts easily and provides a reliable spare for light-duty use.
However, the low load capacity makes it unsuitable for heavier trailers like large boats or campers. Also, the bias-ply construction is less stable at higher speeds. If your trailer is light and you tow at moderate speeds, this spare works well. For heavier loads, look for a higher capacity option.
- Small diameter tire ideal for light-duty utility and jet ski trailers.
- Bias-ply construction for affordability.
- White spoke steel wheel for a classic look.
Pros: Compact size fits small trailers easily.; Lightweight and easy to handle.
Cons: Low load capacity limits use to very light trailers.
6. Wheel Master Trailer Wheel and Tire Combo: Budget Pick
Our comparison of budget spares shows that the Wheel Master combo offers a low-cost solution for trailer owners who need a spare for occasional use. The bias-ply tire and painted steel rim meet basic requirements, and the 2150-pound capacity covers many utility and boat trailers. Owner feedback notes that it fits standard 5-lug hubs without issues.
However, this spare is not recommended for frequent highway towing due to heat buildup in bias-ply tires. The paint finish is less durable than powder coating or galvanizing, so rust may appear sooner. If you need a spare for emergency use or short trips, it is a functional choice. For regular long-distance towing, a radial spare is safer.
- Bias-ply tire for basic spare needs.
- Black painted steel rim.
- Pre-assembled and ready to install.
Pros: Very low price point.; Adequate load capacity for most single-axle trailers.
Cons: Bias-ply tire prone to heat buildup on long highway trips.; Paint finish may chip over time.
7. Maxxis M8008 ST Trailer Tire and Wheel: Durable Choice
Based on owner feedback and spec sheets, the Maxxis M8008 is known for its durability and long tread life. The radial construction provides stable handling and reduced heat buildup, making it suitable for highway towing. The powder-coated steel rim resists corrosion well. Many owners report using this spare for years without issues.
However, it is priced a bit higher than some other radial spares, which may deter budget shoppers. Also, some users found the tire to be slightly stiffer than expected, which can affect ride comfort on rough roads. If you prioritize longevity and are willing to spend a little more, this is a reliable choice. For those on a tight budget, the Kenda Loadstar offers similar capacity at a lower cost.
- Radial tire with a robust tread design for long life.
- Steel rim with a durable powder coat finish.
- Built to handle heavy loads and rough roads.
Pros: Excellent tread wear and longevity.; Radial construction for stable towing.
Cons: Slightly higher price than some comparable options.
Frequently Asked Questions
What size spare wheel do I need for my trailer?
To find the correct size, check the sidewall of your existing trailer tires for the size designation (e.g., ST205/75R15). Also verify the bolt pattern and wheel diameter. You can measure the bolt pattern by measuring from the center of one lug hole to the center of the opposite hole (for 5-lug, it is usually 4.5 or 5 inches). Always match the load rating to at least the maximum load of your trailer’s axle.
Can I use a car tire as a spare for my trailer?
No, car tires are not designed for trailer use. Trailer tires (ST) have reinforced sidewalls and higher load capacities to handle the demands of towing. Using a car tire can lead to tire failure, especially at highway speeds. Always use a tire specifically rated for trailer service.
What is the difference between radial and bias-ply trailer tires?
Radial tires have steel belts running perpendicular to the tread, offering better heat dissipation, stability, and longer tread life at highway speeds. Bias-ply tires have layers of fabric at angles, making them more affordable but prone to heat buildup at higher speeds. For frequent highway towing, radial tires are recommended. For occasional low-speed use, bias-ply can suffice.
How should I store a spare trailer wheel?
Store the spare in a dry, cool place away from direct sunlight and ozone sources like electric motors. If mounted on the trailer, use a cover to protect from UV rays. Check the tire pressure periodically (typically 50-65 psi for ST tires) and inspect for cracks or dry rot, especially if the spare is not used for long periods.
Can I use a spare wheel with a different bolt pattern?
No, the bolt pattern must match exactly for the wheel to fit safely. Adapters are available but are not recommended for spare wheels because they can alter the offset and load distribution. Always purchase a spare with the same bolt pattern as your trailer’s hubs.
Our Verdict
After comparing specs, safety standards, and owner feedback, the Taskmaster Premium Trailer Wheel and Tire Combo earns our top recommendation for its balanced performance, durability, and value. For those willing to invest in premium safety and longevity, the Goodyear Endurance is an excellent runner-up, especially for frequent highway towing.
