Moving large round bales of hay requires a strong, reliable hay spear that can handle heavy loads without bending or breaking. We researched and compared the most popular hay spears on the market, evaluating their build quality, capacity ratings, and owner feedback. This guide covers seven top options, from affordable bale spikes to heavy-duty clamp-on models, so you can choose the best hay spear for your truck, tractor, or skid steer.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Worksaver 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear Best Overall 2 spikes, 3/4 inch steel, fits standard 2 inch receiver |
9.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Titan 3-Spike Hay Bale Spear Runner Up 3 spikes, 5/8 inch steel, 2 inch receiver |
8.9 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
K&K Hay Spear 2-Spike Clamp-On Best Clamp-On Clamp-on design, 2 spikes, fits up to 8 inch square tube |
8.5 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
SpeeCo 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear Best Value 2 spikes, 5/8 inch steel, fits 2 inch receiver |
8.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
Bush Hog 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear Premium Pick 2 spikes, 3/4 inch steel, heavy-duty gussets |
8.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
Tarter 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear Heavy-Duty Choice 2 spikes, 5/8 inch steel, 2 inch receiver with anti-rattle |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
Hesston 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear Lightweight Option 2 spikes, 1/2 inch steel, compact design |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Worksaver 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear: Best Overall
The Worksaver 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear is a top-tier choice for anyone needing a reliable hay spear for their truck. In our evaluation, we compared its 3/4 inch solid steel spikes against competitors and found them to be among the thickest and most durable. Owner feedback consistently praises its ability to handle large round bales without flexing or bending. The welded gussets at the base add extra reinforcement where stress is highest. It’s designed for standard 2 inch receivers, making it easy to install on most trucks.
However, this spear is quite heavy, which can be a downside for those who frequently remove and reinstall it. Some users with smaller trucks reported that the weight affected their payload capacity. If you need a lighter option for occasional use, consider a single-spike model. But for heavy-duty, daily bale moving, the Worksaver is hard to beat.
- Two 3/4 inch solid steel spikes for secure bale handling
- Welded construction with reinforced gussets for strength
- Compatible with most 2 inch receiver hitches
Pros: Excellent build quality with heavy-duty welds; Spikes resist bending even with large bales
Cons: Heavy, adds significant weight to the hitch
2. Titan 3-Spike Hay Bale Spear: Runner Up
The Titan 3-Spike Hay Bale Spear offers a unique advantage with its three spikes, which we found helps stabilize bales that are misshapen or partially broken. In our comparison of owner feedback, many users appreciated the added security when moving large hay bales on uneven terrain. The 5/8 inch spikes are still robust, and the included safety chain adds peace of mind. It’s designed for Cat 1 quick hitches, making it versatile for both trucks and compact tractors.
That said, the 5/8 inch spikes are not as thick as the 3/4 inch found on some rivals. While we saw no reports of bending under normal use, those moving extremely heavy or wet bales may prefer a thicker spike. Also, the three-spike design can make it slightly harder to center on a bale. If you typically handle standard round bales, this is a solid performer, but for the heaviest loads, consider the Worksaver.
- Three 5/8 inch spikes for better bale stability
- Cat 1 quick hitch compatible
- Includes safety chain and hardware
Pros: Three spikes provide excellent grip on uneven bales; Quick hitch compatible for easy attachment
Cons: Spikes slightly thinner than some competitors
3. K&K Hay Spear 2-Spike Clamp-On: Best Clamp-On
For those who don’t have a receiver hitch or prefer a clamp-on solution, the K&K Hay Spear 2-Spike Clamp-On is a convenient option. Our research shows it fits square tubes up to 8 inches, making it compatible with many truck bumpers and trailer hitches. The adjustable clamps allow for a secure fit without welding, and the replaceable spike tips are a nice touch for longevity. Owner feedback highlights its ease of use for occasional hay moving.
However, we noted some concerns about clamp slippage under heavy loads. Users who frequently move large bales reported needing to retighten the clamps periodically. The 5/8 inch spikes are adequate but not as robust as welded models. This spear is best for light to moderate use. If you need a permanent heavy-duty solution, a receiver-mounted spear is a better choice.
- No welding or drilling required for installation
- Adjustable clamps fit various tube sizes
- Two 5/8 inch spikes with replaceable tips
Pros: Easy to install and remove without tools; Replaceable spike tips extend product life
Cons: Clamps may loosen over time with heavy use
4. SpeeCo 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear: Best Value
The SpeeCo 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear is a budget-friendly option that still gets the job done for lighter bales. In our evaluation, we found its 5/8 inch spikes and lightweight construction make it easy to handle, especially for those who need to remove the spear frequently. The powder-coated finish provides decent corrosion resistance. Owner feedback indicates it works well for small to medium round bales.
That said, this spear is not built for the heaviest use. Several users reported bending the spikes when moving large, wet bales. The welds are adequate but not as robust as premium brands. If you move hay only occasionally and your bales are on the smaller side, this is a solid choice. For heavy daily use, invest in a thicker spike model.
- Affordable price point for budget-conscious buyers
- Powder-coated finish resists rust
- Lightweight design for easy handling
Pros: Good value for the price; Lightweight and easy to install
Cons: Not as durable as higher-priced models
5. Bush Hog 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear: Premium Pick
Bush Hog is a well-known name in agricultural equipment, and their 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear lives up to the reputation. Our research shows it features 3/4 inch solid steel spikes with heat-treated tips that resist wear and bending. The heavy-duty gussets provide additional support, making it suitable for the largest round bales. Owner feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with many noting it handles wet hay without issue.
The main drawback is the price, which is higher than many competitors. While the build quality justifies the cost for frequent users, those on a tight budget may find better value elsewhere. Additionally, the extra weight can be a factor for smaller trucks. If you need a spear that will last for years under daily use, the Bush Hog is a worthy investment.
- 3/4 inch solid steel spikes with heat-treated tips
- Reinforced gussets at base for extra strength
- Fits standard 2 inch receiver
Pros: Extremely durable with heat-treated tips; Excellent build quality from a trusted brand
Cons: Premium price point
6. Tarter 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear: Heavy-Duty Choice
The Tarter 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear stands out with its anti-rattle design, which we found reduces annoying noise when driving with the spear attached. The 5/8 inch spikes are adequate for most bales, and the replaceable tips are a practical feature. Owner feedback indicates it works well for medium to large bales, and the powder coat holds up well against rust.
However, the 5/8 inch spikes may not be ideal for the heaviest bales, especially wet ones. Some users reported minor bending after extended use with very large bales. Also, the anti-rattle mechanism can wear over time. If you primarily handle dry bales and want a quieter ride, this is a good option. For extreme loads, look for a 3/4 inch spike model.
- Anti-rattle design reduces noise during transport
- Spikes are 5/8 inch with replaceable tips
- Black powder coat for corrosion resistance
Pros: Anti-rattle feature is a nice touch; Replaceable tips add longevity
Cons: Spikes thinner than some heavy-duty options
7. Hesston 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear: Lightweight Option
The Hesston 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear is a lightweight, budget-friendly option for those who only need to move small bales occasionally. In our evaluation, its 1/2 inch spikes are significantly thinner than most competitors, making it easy to handle but limiting its capacity. Owner feedback suggests it works for small square bales or mini round bales, but it is not recommended for full-size round bales.
Durability is a concern with this model. Several users reported bent spikes when attempting to move large bales. The welds are also less robust. This spear is best suited for light duty or as a backup. If you regularly move large round bales, skip this model and choose one with thicker spikes.
- Lightweight and easy to handle
- Fits 2 inch receiver
- Ideal for small bales and occasional use
Pros: Very light, easy to install and remove; Low cost for occasional users
Cons: 1/2 inch spikes are not suitable for large bales; Not built for heavy-duty use
Frequently Asked Questions
What size hay spear do I need for my truck?
The size depends on the bales you handle. For standard 4×5 or 5×6 round bales, a 2-spike spear with 5/8 inch or 3/4 inch spikes is sufficient. For larger bales, consider a 3-spike spear for better stability. Ensure your truck’s receiver hitch is rated for the weight of the bales plus the spear.
Can I use a hay spear on a skid steer or tractor?
Yes, many hay spears are designed for both truck receivers and tractor three-point hitches. Look for models that are Cat 1 or Cat 2 compatible. Some spears come with a quick hitch adapter for easy switching between vehicles.
How do I install a hay spear on my truck?
Most hay spears slide into a standard 2 inch receiver hitch and are secured with a hitch pin and clip. No welding or drilling is required. Clamp-on models attach to square tube bumpers or trailer hitches using adjustable clamps. Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions.
What is the weight capacity of a hay spear?
Weight capacity varies by model. Most 2-spike spears with 5/8 inch spikes can handle up to 1,500 lbs, while 3/4 inch spike models can handle up to 2,500 lbs or more. Always check the product specifications and ensure your truck’s hitch is rated for the load.
How do I maintain a hay spear to prevent rust?
After each use, clean off dirt and hay residue. Apply a light coat of oil or rust inhibitor to the spikes and welds. Store the spear in a dry place when not in use. If the paint chips, touch it up to prevent rust. Replaceable tips should be checked periodically and replaced if worn.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing the top hay spears, the Worksaver 2-Spike Hay Bale Spear earns our top pick for its robust 3/4 inch spikes, excellent build quality, and strong owner satisfaction. For those who need a three-spike design for better stability, the Titan 3-Spike Hay Bale Spear is a close runner up. Choose based on your typical bale size and frequency of use.
