7 Best All Round Tires (Researched and Compared)

Finding the ‘best all round tires’ means identifying options that deliver a balanced blend of performance across various conditions, without specializing in one extreme. In our evaluation, we researched and compared numerous models, analyzing manufacturer specifications, published industry standards, and aggregated owner feedback to identify tires that excel in everyday driving, offering reliable traction in wet and dry conditions, reasonable winter capability, and comfortable ride quality.

Our goal is to provide an evidence-based buying guide that helps you make an informed decision, highlighting both the strengths and limitations of each tire. We focus on real-world suitability and overall value, ensuring our recommendations are grounded in extensive data rather than anecdotal claims.

1. Michelin CrossClimate2: Top Pick: All-Weather Versatility

🛒  Check Price on Amazon →

While the Michelin CrossClimate2 is celebrated for its remarkable all-weather performance, especially its strong snow capability for an all-season tire, it’s important to note that its unique V-shaped tread pattern, optimized for snow and water evacuation, can sometimes lead to a slightly firmer ride or marginally increased road noise compared to ultra-quiet, touring-specific tires on perfectly smooth, dry pavement. This is a minor trade-off for its significant gains in adverse conditions.

Drivers who live in regions with consistently mild climates, rarely encounter snow or heavy rain, and prioritize absolute maximum fuel efficiency above all other performance metrics might find the CrossClimate2’s advanced all-weather features to be more than they strictly need. Similarly, those seeking the softest, most isolated ride possible on luxury sedans might prefer a tire designed exclusively for touring comfort and minimal noise, though they would sacrifice the robust all-weather safety margin this tire provides.

• Exceptional wet and dry braking performance based on industry testing.
• Delivers strong grip in light to moderate snow, exceeding typical all-season capabilities.
• Maintains consistent performance across a wide temperature range, enhancing year-round utility.

Pros: Superior all-weather traction and safety.; Long tread life based on owner feedback and warranty.; Comfortable and quiet ride quality.
Cons: May have slightly higher rolling resistance compared to some dedicated summer tires.

2. Continental PureContact LS: Premium Touring Comfort

🛒  Check Price on Amazon →

The Continental PureContact LS excels in delivering a luxurious touring experience with superior comfort and minimal noise, making it a favorite for many sedan and coupe owners. However, based on owner feedback and our comparison of specifications, its performance in heavier snow conditions is merely adequate for an all-season tire. While it handles light winter precipitation well, it lacks the aggressive biting edges and specialized compounds found in tires designed for severe snow, which means deep snow traction can be a limitation.

If you frequently drive in areas that experience significant snowfall or icy conditions, and you prioritize maximum winter safety without switching to dedicated winter tires, you might find the PureContact LS to be insufficient. This tire is best suited for drivers in regions with milder winters or those who are prepared to use a second set of winter tires for true cold-weather confidence.

• Designed for a quiet and comfortable ride, a common highlight in owner reviews.
• Provides confident wet and dry traction, meeting high safety standards.
• Engineered for extended tread life, supported by a competitive mileage warranty.

Pros: Excellent ride comfort and low road noise.; Reliable performance in varied road conditions.; Good tread life expectancy.
Cons: Winter performance, while adequate for light snow, does not match dedicated winter tires.

3. Goodyear Assurance MaxLife: Long-Lasting Value

🛒  Check Price on Amazon →

The Goodyear Assurance MaxLife is engineered with durability and longevity as its primary focus, which it achieves remarkably well. However, this emphasis on extended tread life and comfort means that its handling responsiveness, particularly in aggressive cornering or quick maneuvers, is not as sharp or engaging as tires designed for a sportier driving experience. While perfectly safe and predictable for everyday commuting, it won’t inspire confidence for spirited driving.

Drivers who prioritize dynamic handling, precise steering feel, or frequently engage in more aggressive driving styles should consider other options. This tire is best suited for those who value longevity, a smooth ride, and consistent, reliable performance for daily commuting and family transport over enthusiastic driving dynamics.

• Offers a very long tread life, a key selling point for value-conscious drivers.
• Designed to provide reliable all-season traction in various conditions.
• Engineered for a comfortable and quiet ride over its lifespan.

Pros: Exceptional tread life and durability.; Consistent all-season performance.; Good overall value proposition.
Cons: Handling responsiveness is more geared towards comfort than sporty driving.

4. Pirelli P7 Cinturato All Season Plus II: Refined Performance

🛒  Check Price on Amazon →

The Pirelli P7 Cinturato All Season Plus II delivers a refined driving experience with excellent wet traction and a quiet ride, aligning with its premium touring positioning. However, based on owner feedback and comparisons of published warranties, its projected tread life, while respectable, may not reach the extreme longevity offered by some competitors specifically designed for maximum mileage. While it offers a good balance, some drivers might find themselves replacing these tires sooner than those from brands known for ultra-durable compounds.

For drivers who prioritize the absolute longest possible tread life above all other considerations, and are willing to potentially compromise slightly on the nuanced ride comfort or wet weather grip, there might be other options that offer a more extended lifespan. This tire is ideal for those who value a balance of comfort, quietness, and reliable all-season performance, and who do not necessarily need the industry-leading treadwear warranty.

• Provides a quiet and comfortable ride, a common praise in owner feedback.
• Offers strong wet and dry traction, consistent with premium all-season expectations.
• Engineered with a focus on fuel efficiency through lower rolling resistance.

Pros: Quiet and refined ride quality.; Good wet weather performance.; Contributes to fuel efficiency.
Cons: Tread life, while competitive, may not be as exceptional as some ultra-long-lasting rivals.

5. Cooper CS5 Ultra Touring: Solid Mid-Range Performer

🛒  Check Price on Amazon →

The Cooper CS5 Ultra Touring presents a compelling option for a mid-range all-season tire, offering a solid balance of comfort and reliable traction. However, in our evaluation, its snow performance, while meeting basic all-season requirements, is not particularly strong compared to some of the more advanced all-weather specific tires on the market. It handles light snow and slush adequately, but drivers might find themselves wishing for more grip in deeper snow or on icy patches.

If you live in an area that regularly experiences significant winter weather, particularly heavy snowfall or prolonged icy conditions, and you are seeking a tire that truly excels in those challenging environments without needing to switch to dedicated winter tires, the Cooper CS5 Ultra Touring may not fully meet your expectations for winter confidence. It is a suitable choice for regions with milder winters or for drivers who have access to alternative transportation during severe winter events.

• Offers a balanced mix of wet and dry traction for everyday driving.
• Designed to provide a comfortable ride with reasonable road noise levels.
• Competitively priced for its performance capabilities in the mid-range segment.

Pros: Good all-season performance for the value.; Comfortable ride.; Reliable handling in varied conditions.
Cons: Snow performance is adequate but not a standout feature.

6. BFGoodrich Advantage T/A Sport LT: Dependable All-Season

🛒  Check Price on Amazon →

The BFGoodrich Advantage T/A Sport LT is a robust all-season option, particularly for light trucks and SUVs, offering dependable performance and good durability. However, based on owner feedback, one common observation is that the road noise can become more noticeable over time, particularly as the tires wear. While initially acceptable, it may not maintain the whisper-quiet ride of some premium touring tires throughout its entire lifespan, especially on certain road surfaces.

Drivers who are highly sensitive to road noise, or those who frequently travel long distances and prioritize an exceptionally quiet cabin experience above all else, might find this characteristic to be a drawback. This tire is a strong contender for those seeking a durable, reliable all-season tire for trucks and SUVs where overall utility and dependable performance are prioritized over absolute acoustic refinement.

• Offers dependable all-season traction for a variety of vehicles.
• Constructed for durability and a good service life.
• Provides a comfortable ride for daily commuting and highway travel.

Pros: Reliable wet and dry grip.; Good durability and treadwear.; Solid value in its category.
Cons: Road noise can be more noticeable than premium touring tires over time.

7. Firestone All Season: Budget-Friendly Basic

🛒  Check Price on Amazon →

The Firestone All Season tire serves as a straightforward, budget-friendly option for general purpose driving, delivering on its promise of basic all-season utility. However, in our comparison, its overall performance, particularly in more challenging conditions like moderate to heavy snow or aggressive maneuvering, is noticeably less refined and capable than premium or even mid-range alternatives. While it will get you through light winter conditions, it lacks the advanced grip and stability features of higher-tier tires.

Drivers who regularly encounter significant winter weather, demand strong handling responsiveness, or prioritize the absolute highest levels of wet and dry grip and braking performance for enhanced safety margins, should consider investing in a more advanced tire. This tire is best suited for those with limited budgets, driving in mild climates, and whose primary concern is reliable, no-frills transportation without pushing performance limits.

• An accessible option for drivers seeking basic all-season functionality.
• Provides acceptable traction for everyday dry and wet conditions.
• Designed for reliable, no-frills performance and good value.

Pros: Very good value proposition.; Reliable for basic daily driving needs.; Decent wet weather performance for its class.
Cons: Overall performance, particularly in winter conditions, is basic compared to premium options.

Frequently Asked Questions

What defines an 'all round tire'?

An ‘all round tire,’ often synonymous with an ‘all-season tire,’ is designed to offer a balanced performance across various weather conditions, including dry, wet, and light snow. It aims to provide acceptable traction, comfort, and longevity without excelling in any single extreme, making it a versatile choice for most drivers who experience moderate climate changes.

Are all-season tires truly good in snow?

While all-season tires are designed to handle light snow and slush, their performance in severe winter conditions, such as deep snow or ice, is generally inferior to dedicated winter tires. Some advanced ‘all-weather’ tires, like the Michelin CrossClimate2, carry the three-peak mountain snowflake (3PMSF) symbol, indicating they meet specific performance requirements for severe snow, offering a stronger all-round winter capability than standard all-season options.

How does tread life compare across different all-round tires?

Tread life for all-round tires can vary significantly based on the manufacturer’s design philosophy and compound choices. Some tires, like the Goodyear Assurance MaxLife, prioritize extreme longevity with very high treadwear ratings and extended warranties. Others may balance tread life with performance characteristics like grip or quietness. Always check the specific tire’s treadwear rating and warranty information for expected lifespan.

Do 'all round' tires impact fuel efficiency?

Yes, the design of an all-round tire can impact fuel efficiency through its rolling resistance. Tires with lower rolling resistance are engineered to reduce the energy required to keep them moving, potentially leading to better fuel economy. Many modern all-season tires incorporate technologies to minimize rolling resistance while maintaining other performance attributes.

What are the trade-offs of choosing an all-round tire instead of specialized tires?

The primary trade-off is that an all-round tire will not perform as optimally as a specialized tire in its specific extreme. For instance, it won’t offer the peak dry grip and handling of a dedicated summer performance tire, nor the superior deep snow and ice traction of a dedicated winter tire. It’s a compromise designed for convenience and versatility, aiming for good performance across the board rather than exceptional performance in one specific area.

Our Verdict

After extensive research and comparison, the Michelin CrossClimate2 stands out as our top pick for the best all round tire, offering unparalleled all-weather versatility and safety, especially its impressive snow capability for an all-season option. For drivers prioritizing premium comfort and quietness with reliable all-season performance, the Continental PureContact LS is an excellent runner-up, providing a refined driving experience.