Navigating the diverse landscape of all-terrain tires for your 225/65R17 vehicle can be challenging. Our team at MustCarBeast has thoroughly researched and compared the leading options in this popular size, evaluating them against manufacturer specifications, published industry standards, and extensive aggregated owner feedback.
This buying guide presents our findings to help you make an informed decision, focusing on performance, durability, safety, and overall value without relying on anecdotal claims or fabricated tests. We aim to provide an honest assessment of what each tire offers and where its limitations lie.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO2 Top Pick CoreGard Technology for enhanced sidewall toughness. |
9.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Falken Wildpeak A/T3W Runner-Up Heat diffuser technology in the lower sidewall dissipates heat. |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Goodyear Wrangler All-Terrain Adventure with Kevlar Strong Performer Layers of DuPont Kevlar for enhanced strength and durability. |
8.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Toyo Open Country A/T III All-Weather Ready New tread compound and design for improved wet and winter performance. |
8.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Nitto Terra Grappler G2 Quiet Ride Coupling joints connect tread blocks to increase rigidity. |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus Durable Choice Robust tread compound for increased resistance to chips and cuts. |
7.5 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Kumho Road Venture AT51 Best Value Dual-pitch, variable tread design for reduced road noise. |
7.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO2: Top Pick
In our evaluation, the BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO2 consistently stands out for its robust construction and formidable off-road capabilities. While its performance in challenging terrains is undeniable, based on owner feedback, a common limitation is its on-road comfort. Some owners report a noticeable increase in road noise, particularly at highway speeds, which is a trade-off for its aggressive tread pattern and durable build.
Drivers who prioritize a whisper-quiet ride and spend the vast majority of their time on paved roads might find the KO2 to be more tire than they need. While it performs admirably on pavement, its true strengths lie off the beaten path. If your driving is predominantly urban or highway, and occasional light trails are the exception, a tire with a more road-biased design might offer a more refined daily driving experience.
- Aggressive, interlocking tread design for excellent traction in varied conditions.
- Features 3D sipes for improved grip on wet roads and light snow.
- Shoulder design extends traction capabilities into mud and soft soil.
Pros: Exceptional off-road grip and durability based on owner feedback and design specs.; Highly resistant to punctures and bruising, a key safety benefit.; Dependable performance in diverse weather conditions, including winter.
Cons: Can be louder on highway driving compared to less aggressive options.; Slightly heavier, which may impact fuel efficiency for some vehicles.
2. Falken Wildpeak A/T3W: Runner-Up
The Falken Wildpeak A/T3W consistently earns high marks in our research for its balanced performance across various conditions. While it excels in many areas, based on owner feedback, one area of slight concern for some is a gradual increase in road noise as the tire wears. This is a common characteristic for all-terrain tires, but some owners note it becomes more pronounced compared to initial impressions.
For drivers seeking absolute silence on the highway, especially after several thousand miles, this characteristic might be a minor detractor. However, considering its strong performance in wet, dry, and snowy conditions, and its robust construction, the Wildpeak A/T3W remains a top contender for those who need a versatile tire that can handle light to moderate off-road adventures and daily commuting effectively.
- Full depth sipes and tread blocks maintain consistent performance throughout the tire's life.
- Outer Apex Sidewall provides an additional layer of protection against sharp objects.
- Features a severe snow rating (3PMSF) for confident winter driving.
Pros: Offers a strong balance of off-road traction and on-road comfort.; Excellent wet weather and snow performance, enhancing safety.; Durable construction with good resistance to punctures and abrasions.
Cons: Some owners report a slight increase in road noise over time.; May not be as aggressive in extreme mud as dedicated mud-terrain tires.
3. Goodyear Wrangler All-Terrain Adventure with Kevlar: Strong Performer
The Goodyear Wrangler All-Terrain Adventure with Kevlar is highly praised in our evaluation for its blend of on-road civility and off-road capability, bolstered by its Kevlar reinforcement. However, based on owner feedback, its primary limitation for some lies in its performance in more severe off-road conditions, such as deep mud or highly technical trails. While it handles light to moderate off-roading with ease, its tread design is not as aggressive as some dedicated all-terrain or hybrid-terrain options, which can limit traction in truly challenging environments.
Drivers who frequently tackle very muddy trails or require maximum grip in extreme off-road scenarios might find this tire to be a compromise. If your off-road excursions are more adventurous than light trail driving, you might consider tires with a more pronounced, open tread pattern designed for aggressive mud-shedding. For everyday driving with occasional off-road use, it remains a very strong, durable choice.
- Open shoulder blocks help clear mud and snow for improved traction.
- Durawall Technology provides resistance to cuts and punctures in the sidewall.
- Optimized tread pattern designed for a quiet ride on paved roads.
Pros: Kevlar reinforcement provides exceptional durability and puncture resistance.; Good on-road manners with a relatively quiet and comfortable ride.; Reliable traction in various conditions, including light snow.
Cons: Some owners find its off-road capability less extreme than more aggressive AT tires.; Value proposition can be less competitive compared to other strong AT options.
4. Toyo Open Country A/T III: All-Weather Ready
The Toyo Open Country A/T III represents a significant evolution in all-terrain performance, with our research highlighting its improved wet and winter traction. However, in our evaluation and based on owner feedback, a minor drawback for some users is that while its on-road noise is generally acceptable for an all-terrain tire, it isn’t as quiet as a dedicated highway touring tire. The more aggressive tread design, necessary for its off-road prowess, inherently generates a bit more road noise.
For drivers who are highly sensitive to tire noise and primarily drive on smooth pavement, this characteristic might be a consideration. While it offers a comfortable ride for an AT tire, those seeking absolute quietude might prefer a different category of tire. However, for a balanced performance that handles diverse conditions, including winter, the A/T III is a very capable option.
- More aggressive, irregular tread blocks enhance off-road grip and durability.
- Features a balanced void ratio for excellent stone ejection and reduced noise.
- Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake (3PMSF) rated for severe snow conditions.
Pros: Improved wet braking and handling compared to previous generations, enhancing safety.; Strong off-road traction in dirt, gravel, and light mud.; Good balance between on-road comfort and off-road capability.
Cons: Some owners report it can still be slightly louder than pure highway tires.; Off-road durability, while good, may not match the absolute toughest options.
5. Nitto Terra Grappler G2: Quiet Ride
The Nitto Terra Grappler G2 is often lauded in owner feedback for its remarkably quiet and comfortable on-road performance, a significant advantage for an all-terrain tire. However, our evaluation indicates that its main limitation surfaces when venturing into more challenging off-road conditions, particularly deep mud or loose terrain. The tread pattern, while effective for general off-road use, is not as aggressive or open as some other all-terrain options, which can compromise its ability to clear mud and maintain traction in severe scenarios.
Drivers who frequently encounter extreme mud or highly technical trails might find the Terra Grappler G2’s performance to be less than ideal in those specific situations. If your off-road adventures are more focused on gravel roads, dry trails, and light dirt, this tire provides an excellent balance of comfort and capability. For serious mudding, a more specialized or aggressive all-terrain tire would likely be a better fit.
- Full depth sipes provide consistent tread block flexibility for wet and winter traction.
- Staggered shoulder lugs offer additional biting edges for off-road performance.
- Designed to offer a comfortable and relatively quiet on-road experience.
Pros: Notably quiet for an all-terrain tire, enhancing on-road comfort.; Good performance in dry and wet conditions, reliable safety.; Offers a smooth ride quality, making it suitable for daily driving.
Cons: Less aggressive off-road traction compared to some competitors, especially in mud.; Not severe snow rated (3PMSF), limiting its winter performance in harsh conditions.
6. Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus: Durable Choice
The Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus, in our research, is recognized for its durable construction and solid all-terrain performance. However, based on owner feedback, a consistent point of critique revolves around its on-road noise levels. While acceptable for an aggressive all-terrain tire, it tends to be louder on paved surfaces, especially at highway speeds, when compared to more road-oriented all-terrain options or pure highway tires.
Drivers who prioritize a quiet cabin experience for long highway commutes and only occasionally venture off-road might find this characteristic to be a drawback. While it offers good traction and durability for off-road use, those seeking a tire that minimizes road noise for daily driving may wish to explore other options. If off-road durability and traction are higher priorities than absolute on-road quietness, this tire remains a viable choice.
- Aggressive tread pattern with large, robust blocks for off-road traction.
- Conical stone ejectors help prevent stone retention and drilling.
- Features a full-depth siping system for consistent wet and snow grip.
Pros: Good durability and resistance to off-road damage.; Provides confident traction in various conditions, including light snow.; Relatively good wet weather performance, contributing to safety.
Cons: Can be louder on the highway than some competitors in its class.; Some owners report its on-road comfort is not its strongest attribute.
7. Kumho Road Venture AT51: Best Value
The Kumho Road Venture AT51, as per our research and aggregated owner feedback, delivers a commendable balance of all-terrain performance and value. However, a notable limitation is its overall refinement on paved roads. While it attempts to minimize road noise with its dual-pitch design, it doesn’t quite match the quietness or ride comfort of more premium or road-focused all-terrain tires. Some owners report a firmer ride quality and more audible road noise, particularly on less-than-perfect pavement.
Drivers who prioritize a luxurious or exceptionally quiet on-road experience for their daily commute might find these characteristics less appealing. If your budget is a primary consideration and you need a capable all-terrain tire with good winter performance, the AT51 offers strong value. However, if plush comfort and minimal cabin noise are at the top of your list, you might consider investing in a tire from a higher-tier category.
- Angled chamfer blocks promote self-cleaning for improved mud and snow traction.
- Features 3D sipes for enhanced grip on wet and icy surfaces.
- Cut and chip resistant compound for durability in rough terrain.
Pros: Offers good all-terrain capability for its value proposition.; Features a 3PMSF rating, providing reliable winter traction.; Durable construction with good resistance to cuts and chips.
Cons: On-road comfort and noise levels are not as refined as premium options.; Off-road performance, while decent, is not exceptional in extreme conditions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does 225/65R17 mean for a tire?
The number 225 refers to the tire’s width in millimeters. 65 is the aspect ratio, meaning the sidewall height is 65% of the width. R indicates radial construction, and 17 signifies the tire is designed for a 17-inch wheel rim. This size is common for many compact and mid-size SUVs.
Are all-terrain tires suitable for daily driving on pavement?
Yes, modern all-terrain tires are designed to offer a good balance of on-road manners and off-road capability. While they may be slightly louder or offer a firmer ride than pure highway tires, they are perfectly suitable for daily driving and provide enhanced traction for varied weather conditions and occasional light off-road excursions.
What is the Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake (3PMSF) symbol?
The 3PMSF symbol indicates that a tire meets specific performance criteria in severe snow conditions, as tested by an independent third party. Tires with this rating offer superior traction in winter weather compared to standard all-season or all-terrain tires without the symbol, providing an added layer of safety.
Do all-terrain tires wear faster than highway tires?
Generally, all-terrain tires are constructed with tougher compounds and more aggressive tread patterns, which can sometimes lead to slightly faster wear on paved roads compared to highway-specific tires. However, many modern all-terrain tires now feature advanced compounds and designs that offer competitive tread life, especially if properly maintained with regular rotations.
How important is sidewall strength in an all-terrain tire?
Sidewall strength is very important for all-terrain tires, particularly when driving off-road. A robust sidewall helps protect against punctures and abrasions from rocks, stumps, and other obstacles, which are common hazards in rough terrain. Enhanced sidewall protection contributes significantly to the tire’s durability and overall safety during off-road adventures.
Our Verdict
After extensive research and comparison, the BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO2 stands out as our Top Pick for the best 225/65R17 all-terrain tire, offering an unparalleled blend of off-road durability, traction, and reliable performance across diverse conditions. For those seeking a strong alternative with excellent balanced performance and value, the Falken Wildpeak A/T3W is an exceptional Runner-Up, providing robust all-weather capability and a comfortable ride.
