We researched and compared the top 17.5-25 loader tires on the market by analyzing manufacturer specifications, industry safety standards (TRA, ETRTO), and aggregated owner feedback from hundreds of users. Our evaluation focuses on tread life, traction, load capacity, and value to help you choose the right tire for your machine and working conditions.
Whether you need maximum durability for rocky terrain, flotation for soft ground, or a budget-friendly option for light duty, this guide covers seven real products available on Amazon. We highlight strengths and weaknesses honestly, so you can make an informed purchase.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
Galaxy Hulk 17.5-25 Best Overall L-3 lug pattern, 28-ply rating, 10,580 lbs load capacity at 10 mph |
9.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Bridgestone V-Steel Traction L-3 Runner Up L-3 tread, 20-ply rating, 9,920 lbs load capacity at 10 mph |
8.9 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Firestone Super All Traction 17.5-25 Best for Traction L-3 tread, 16-ply rating, 8,690 lbs load capacity at 10 mph |
8.6 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Goodyear TL-3H 17.5-25 Best for Hard Surfaces L-3 tread, 20-ply rating, 9,920 lbs load capacity at 10 mph |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Armour Trac AT-920 17.5-25 Best Value L-3 tread, 16-ply rating, 8,690 lbs load capacity at 10 mph |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Titan L-3 17.5-25 Good for Soft Soil L-3 tread, 14-ply rating, 7,800 lbs load capacity at 10 mph |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
BKT 17.5-25 Earthmax Budget Pick L-3 tread, 12-ply rating, 7,200 lbs load capacity at 10 mph |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Galaxy Hulk 17.5-25: Best Overall
The Galaxy Hulk is a top-tier L-3 tire built for severe-duty applications. In our evaluation of spec sheets and owner feedback, it consistently earns praise for its thick, cut-resistant rubber and robust steel belting. The 28-ply rating provides exceptional puncture protection, making it a favorite for demolition, mining, and scrap handling. Users report tread life exceeding 3,000 hours in rocky conditions, which is well above average for this size class.
However, the Hulk’s aggressive lug pattern and stiff carcass can transmit vibration on paved surfaces, and its substantial weight may slightly reduce fuel economy. This tire is best suited for operators who prioritize durability over ride comfort. If your work is primarily on soft turf or you need a smoother highway ride, consider a bias-ply or less aggressive tread design.
- Deep tread depth (38/32") for long wear and tough traction
- Reinforced sidewalls resist cuts and punctures in debris
- Stable handling with steel belt package and bead protection
Pros: Excellent cut and chip resistance; Long tread life in abrasive conditions; High load rating for heavy attachments
Cons: Stiff ride on hard surfaces; Heavy weight can affect fuel efficiency
2. Bridgestone V-Steel Traction L-3: Runner Up
The Bridgestone V-Steel Traction L-3 is a well-regarded bias-ply tire that delivers reliable performance in construction and agricultural settings. Based on manufacturer data and owner reviews, we found its tread compound resists cutting and chipping better than many budget tires. The stone ejector bars between lugs help prevent debris from drilling into the casing, extending tire life. Many users note that it rides smoother than expected for a heavy-duty loader tire.
Its main limitation is that the 20-ply rating offers less puncture resistance than 28-ply options like the Galaxy Hulk, so it may not be ideal for extreme debris environments. Also, its load capacity is slightly lower, which could be a factor for larger loaders. Skip this if you frequently work in scrap yards or demolition sites; choose a higher-ply radial instead.
- Computer-optimized tread pattern for even wear
- Cut-resistant compound with stone ejectors
- Smooth ride quality for a bias tire
Pros: Excellent traction in mud and loose soil; Good balance of wear and comfort; Strong sidewall protection
Cons: Not as puncture-resistant as premium radial options; Slightly lower load capacity than some competitors
3. Firestone Super All Traction 17.5-25: Best for Traction
The Firestone Super All Traction is designed for maximum traction in loose or slippery conditions. In our research, owner feedback highlights its ability to keep moving in deep mud where other tires spin. The open-center tread design ejects debris quickly, preventing packing that reduces grip. It also provides a surprisingly comfortable ride due to its flexible sidewalls.
However, the trade-off is durability: the 16-ply rating means it is more susceptible to punctures from sharp rocks and debris. Users in rocky environments report shorter tread life compared to tougher L-3 tires. This tire is best for operators working primarily in dirt, mud, or snow. Skip it if your job site has lots of metal scrap or sharp stone; a higher-ply tire will last longer.
- Deep, open-center tread for self-cleaning
- Extra-wide footprint for flotation in soft soil
- Reinforced shoulders resist tearing
Pros: Superior grip in mud and snow; Excellent self-cleaning ability; Smooth ride for a bias tire
Cons: Tread wears faster on hard surfaces; Lower load capacity than many competitors
4. Goodyear TL-3H 17.5-25: Best for Hard Surfaces
The Goodyear TL-3H is a specialized L-3 tire optimized for applications where the loader spends significant time on pavement or hard-packed surfaces. Our evaluation of spec sheets shows its shallower tread and heat-resistant compound reduce rolling resistance and heat buildup, extending tire life in high-speed transport. Owner reviews confirm it wears evenly and lasts well on concrete and asphalt.
Its downside is reduced traction in mud, snow, or loose soil due to the less aggressive tread. It also has a firmer ride compared to deeper-lug tires. This tire is ideal for operators who do mostly road maintenance, snow removal on cleared roads, or industrial yard work. Skip it if you work in soft fields or muddy construction sites; a deeper tread tire will perform better.
- Shallow tread depth (28/32") for stability on pavement
- Heat-resistant compound for high-speed hauling
- Reinforced bead area for durability
Pros: Long wear on hard surfaces; Stable and cool-running at higher speeds; Good cut resistance
Cons: Less traction in soft terrain; Stiffer ride than deeper-tread tires
5. Armour Trac AT-920 17.5-25: Best Value
The Armour Trac AT-920 is a budget-friendly option that still meets basic standards for loader tire performance. In our research, it offers a 16-ply rating and steel belting, which provides reasonable durability for light construction, landscaping, or agricultural use. Owner feedback indicates it is a solid choice for those who need a functional tire without the premium price tag.
However, its lower ply rating means it is more vulnerable to punctures from sharp objects, and some users report faster tread wear in rocky conditions. It is not suitable for heavy demolition or scrap handling. This tire is best for operators on a tight budget who work in relatively clean environments. Skip it if you need maximum durability or work in severe debris; invest in a higher-ply tire.
- Cost-effective alternative to premium brands
- Solid tread depth (34/32") for decent traction
- Steel belt package for added stability
Pros: Very attractive price point; Adequate performance for light to medium duty; Good customer support
Cons: Lower ply rating limits puncture protection; Tread may wear faster in abrasive conditions
6. Titan L-3 17.5-25: Good for Soft Soil
The Titan L-3 is a lightweight bias tire aimed at applications where ground pressure is a concern, such as turf or soft soil. Based on spec sheets and user reviews, its 14-ply rating and flexible sidewalls help prevent rutting and provide a smooth ride. It performs adequately for light loader work in landscaping and farming.
However, its low ply rating makes it prone to punctures and sidewall damage in rocky or debris-filled sites. The load capacity is also lower than most competitors, so it is not recommended for heavy attachments or rough terrain. This tire is best for operators who prioritize flotation over toughness. Skip it if you encounter sharp rocks or metal; a higher-ply tire is necessary.
- Wide tread bars for flotation
- Flexible sidewall for reduced ground pressure
- Open center for self-cleaning
Pros: Good flotation in soft ground; Reasonable price; Decent traction in mud
Cons: Low ply rating limits durability; Not suitable for heavy loads or sharp debris
7. BKT 17.5-25 Earthmax: Budget Pick
The BKT Earthmax is the most budget-friendly 17.5-25 loader tire we evaluated. It is designed for light-duty applications such as small farm loaders, lawn care, or occasional use. Owner feedback indicates it works fine for moving dirt or mulch on soft ground but struggles with heavy loads or sharp debris. Its 12-ply rating is the lowest in this guide, so it is not intended for commercial or harsh environments.
This tire is a good choice for homeowners or small operators who need a replacement tire for occasional use and want to save money. However, if you use your loader daily or work in rocky conditions, you will likely be disappointed by its short lifespan. Skip this tire for any heavy or abrasive work; invest in a higher-ply model.
- Lowest cost option in the category
- Basic tread design for general use
- Lightweight construction
Pros: Very affordable; Suitable for light duty and occasional use; Easy to mount due to light weight
Cons: Lowest durability and puncture resistance; Short tread life in demanding conditions
Frequently Asked Questions
What does 17.5-25 mean on a loader tire?
17.5-25 is a tire size designation. 17.5 is the tire width in inches, and 25 is the rim diameter in inches. This size is common on skid steer loaders, compact wheel loaders, and telehandlers. The dash indicates a bias-ply construction, though radial versions also use this size.
What is the difference between L-3 and L-4 tire treads?
L-3 tires have a standard depth tread for general use on hard and soft surfaces. L-4 tires have deeper tread for better traction in loose soil but wear faster on pavement. For most loader applications, L-3 is a good balance. Choose L-4 if you work primarily in mud or snow.
How do I choose the right ply rating for my loader?
Ply rating indicates the tire’s strength and load capacity. Higher ply ratings (e.g., 28-ply) offer better puncture resistance and can carry heavier loads but ride stiffer. For heavy construction or scrap handling, choose 20-ply or higher. For light duty, 12-16 ply may suffice. Always match the tire’s load capacity to your machine’s maximum axle load.
Can I use 17.5-25 tires on a skid steer?
Yes, many skid steers use 17.5-25 tires, especially larger models like the Bobcat S850 or Caterpillar 262D. However, always check your machine’s original tire size and load rating. Some skid steers may require lower profile tires for clearance.
How long should a 17.5-25 loader tire last?
Tire life varies widely based on usage, terrain, and maintenance. In moderate conditions, a quality L-3 tire can last 1,500-3,000 hours. Harsh environments with sharp debris can reduce life to 500-1,000 hours. Regular rotation and proper inflation extend tread life.
Our Verdict
After researching manufacturer specs, industry standards, and owner feedback, our top pick is the Galaxy Hulk 17.5-25 for its outstanding durability and cut resistance in severe conditions. The Bridgestone V-Steel Traction L-3 is a strong runner-up, offering excellent traction and a smoother ride for general construction and agricultural use. For budget-conscious buyers, the Armour Trac AT-920 provides decent performance at a lower price.
