Selecting the right tires for your UTV or side by side is critical for optimizing performance, handling, and safety across diverse terrains. With a vast array of options available, each engineered for specific conditions from mud to hardpack, the choice can be challenging. Our team at MustCarBeast has extensively researched and compared numerous UTV tire models to help you make an informed decision.
In our evaluation, we analyzed manufacturer specifications, cross-referenced industry safety standards, and aggregated feedback from hundreds of UTV owners. This rigorous process allowed us to identify the strengths and limitations of each tire, ensuring our recommendations are evidence-based and genuinely useful for riders seeking the best possible tire setup for their side by side.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Maxxis Bighorn 2.0 Radial Tire Top All-Terrain Performer Radial construction for enhanced ride comfort |
9.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
ITP Mega Mayhem ATV/UTV Tire Best for Mud and Soft Terrain Deep, angled lugs for aggressive mud traction |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Kenda K3201 Mastodon HT Radial Tire Versatile Hard Terrain Option 8-ply rated radial construction |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
CST Lobo RC Radial Tire Rock and Desert Specialist 8-ply rated radial with reinforced sidewalls |
8.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Carlisle Versa Trax AT Radial Tire Solid All-Terrain Value Radial construction with multi-angle tread pattern |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Sedona Rip-Saw R/T Radial Tire Dependable Radial All-Terrain Radial construction with durable 6-ply rating |
7.5 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
SunF Power.I ATV/UTV All-Terrain Radial Tire Budget-Friendly All-Terrain Radial construction with non-directional tread |
7.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Maxxis Bighorn 2.0 Radial Tire: Top All-Terrain Performer
The Maxxis Bighorn 2.0 consistently ranks high in our evaluations for its balanced performance across a wide range of terrains. Its radial construction is a significant factor, providing superior shock absorption and a more comfortable ride, which is particularly noticeable on long excursions or uneven trails. We observed from spec sheets that its non-directional tread offers predictable handling whether you are moving forward or reversing, a feature highly valued by riders navigating complex trails.
However, based on owner feedback and our analysis of its tread design, the Bighorn 2.0, while excellent in most conditions, can struggle with self-cleaning in extremely thick, heavy mud. Riders who primarily operate in deep, boggy environments might find its traction diminishes as the tread voids become packed. Therefore, if your typical riding involves predominantly severe mud, you might consider a more aggressive, purpose-built mud tire.
- Lightweight design based on the original Bighorn
- Non-directional tread pattern for versatile traction
- Radial construction for a smoother ride and better handling
Pros: Exceptional all-terrain capability on varied surfaces; Proven durability with good resistance to punctures; Smooth ride quality praised in owner feedback
Cons: Tread can pack with mud in very deep, sticky conditions; Some owners report faster wear on extremely hard surfaces compared to dedicated hardpack tires
2. ITP Mega Mayhem ATV/UTV Tire: Best for Mud and Soft Terrain
In our evaluation, the ITP Mega Mayhem stands out for its formidable performance in challenging soft conditions. The deep, aggressive lugs, extending onto the sidewall, are specifically engineered to dig through mud, snow, and loose dirt, providing exceptional forward momentum. Based on aggregated owner feedback, its 6-ply rating contributes to a robust construction, offering good resistance against punctures and impacts, which is crucial when navigating debris-strewn trails.
However, the very design features that make the Mega Mayhem excel in mud contribute to its primary limitation: a less comfortable ride on hardpack or asphalt. The large, widely spaced lugs create more vibration and noise at speed on firm surfaces, which some riders found fatiguing. If your riding consists mostly of groomed trails, pavement, or desert hardpack, these tires may not provide the smooth experience you desire, and you might prefer an all-terrain or hardpack-specific tire.
- 6-ply rating for enhanced puncture resistance
- Aggressive 1.5-inch deep lugs for superior mud performance
- Unique tread pattern extends to the sidewall for added grip
Pros: Outstanding traction in mud, snow, and soft soil; Durable construction handles challenging obstacles; Provides excellent ground clearance due to large lug depth
Cons: Rougher ride on hardpack and paved surfaces; Can be heavy, potentially impacting power and fuel efficiency
3. Kenda K3201 Mastodon HT Radial Tire: Versatile Hard Terrain Option
We researched the Kenda K3201 Mastodon HT and found it to be a highly capable tire for riders who frequently encounter hardpack, rocky trails, and intermediate terrains. Its 8-ply radial construction is a key specification, offering a robust defense against punctures and impacts, a common concern on demanding trails. Owner feedback consistently highlights its reliable grip and stability, particularly when climbing over obstacles or navigating technical sections.
Despite its strengths, the Kenda Mastodon HT’s tread pattern, while effective for hard terrain, is not optimized for deep, sticky mud. The tighter lug spacing and overall design, intended for solid ground contact, can lead to mud packing in extreme conditions, reducing its ability to self-clean and maintain traction. Therefore, if your primary riding environment is characterized by extensive, heavy mud, you might find its performance limited compared to dedicated mud tires.
- Designed for hard terrain and intermediate conditions
- Heavy-duty 8-ply rated radial casing for superior strength
- Aggressive tread pattern for traction and stability
Pros: Excellent puncture resistance and sidewall protection; Consistent grip on rocks, roots, and hard-packed trails; Radial design offers a smooth, controlled ride
Cons: Can be less effective in deep, soupy mud; Heavier compared to some competitor tires
4. CST Lobo RC Radial Tire: Rock and Desert Specialist
In our evaluation of the CST Lobo RC, we noted its specific design intent for demanding desert and rocky environments. The 8-ply radial construction, combined with reinforced sidewalls, is a critical specification that provides superior protection against punctures and pinches, which are frequent hazards in rocky terrain. Based on owner feedback, the tire’s robust build instills confidence when tackling sharp edges and uneven surfaces, making it a favorite for rock crawlers and desert racers.
A notable limitation of the Lobo RC, however, is its performance and wear characteristics on hard-packed roads or pavement. The specialized compound and aggressive tread, optimized for maximum grip on abrasive rocks and loose dirt, can experience accelerated wear when subjected to prolonged use on harder, smoother surfaces. Riders who frequently transition between extreme off-road and paved sections may find the lifespan shorter than desired, suggesting a more general-purpose all-terrain tire might be a better fit for mixed-use scenarios.
- Specifically engineered for desert racing and rock crawling
- Extra-tough 8-ply radial casing and reinforced sidewall
- Aggressive, non-directional tread for multi-angle traction
Pros: Exceptional sidewall strength and puncture resistance; Reliable grip on rocks, loose dirt, and desert terrain; Predictable handling in challenging off-road conditions
Cons: Tread wear can be accelerated on hard surfaces; Not ideal for deep mud or soft loam
5. Carlisle Versa Trax AT Radial Tire: Solid All-Terrain Value
We researched the Carlisle Versa Trax AT as a strong contender in the all-terrain category, particularly for its balanced performance and qualitative value. Its radial construction, as highlighted in the manufacturer’s specifications, contributes to a comfortable ride and stable handling across a variety of surfaces. Owner feedback generally praises its ability to transition effectively from hardpack to light mud and loose gravel, making it a versatile choice for recreational riders.
However, in our comparison, while the Versa Trax AT performs competently across the board, it does not excel in any single extreme condition. For instance, its tread design, while versatile, may not provide the aggressive grip needed for deep, heavy mud or the robust puncture resistance required for severe rock crawling, when compared to specialized tires. Riders who push their UTVs into truly extreme environments might find its capabilities fall short of their specific demands, and would benefit from investing in a tire engineered for those particular challenges.
- Radial design for a comfortable ride and improved traction
- Non-directional tread pattern for versatile all-terrain use
- Durable 6-ply rating for reliable performance
Pros: Good all-around performance on various terrains; Offers a smooth and predictable ride; Represents a strong value proposition for its capabilities
Cons: Lacks the extreme performance of specialized tires in specific conditions; Some reports of less aggressive side bite compared to premium options
6. Sedona Rip-Saw R/T Radial Tire: Dependable Radial All-Terrain
In our evaluation, the Sedona Rip-Saw R/T presents itself as a dependable radial all-terrain tire, suitable for a broad spectrum of UTV uses. The radial construction, a key specification, contributes significantly to a smoother ride and enhanced stability, which is often appreciated on long trail rides. Based on aggregated owner feedback, it provides consistent traction on intermediate trails, hardpack, and light mud, making it a reliable choice for general recreational riding.
A common point raised in owner feedback and our analysis of the tread design is that the Rip-Saw R/T can exhibit some vulnerability to chunking, particularly when subjected to aggressive riding over very sharp, jagged rocks. While its 6-ply rating offers good general puncture resistance, the tread compound or pattern may not be as resilient against severe abrasion as some other premium, rock-specific tires. Therefore, if your riding primarily involves highly technical rock crawling or extremely abrasive terrain, you might consider alternatives with more robust tread compounds or higher ply ratings designed for such specific abuse.
- Radial construction for improved ride comfort and stability
- Aggressive tread pattern designed for all-terrain traction
- 6-ply rated carcass for good puncture resistance
Pros: Consistent traction across various terrains; Smooth ride quality for extended trips; Solid construction offers reasonable durability
Cons: Can be prone to chunking on sharp rocks for some users; Tread depth is not as aggressive as some competitors
7. SunF Power.I ATV/UTV All-Terrain Radial Tire: Budget-Friendly All-Terrain
We researched the SunF Power.I as a compelling option for UTV owners seeking a radial all-terrain tire without a premium investment. Its radial construction, as per manufacturer specifications, is a significant advantage in this price segment, contributing to a noticeably smoother ride and better handling characteristics compared to many bias-ply alternatives. Owner feedback indicates that for casual riding on varied terrains, it delivers acceptable performance and traction.
However, a primary limitation noted in our evaluation and aggregated owner feedback is that the long-term durability of the SunF Power.I may not consistently match that of established premium brands, especially under frequent heavy use or aggressive riding conditions. While it offers good value, riders who regularly push their UTVs to their limits, or who demand maximum lifespan and puncture resistance, might find these tires wear faster or are more susceptible to damage than higher-tier options. If extreme durability and performance in the most challenging scenarios are your absolute top priorities, investing in a more robust, higher-priced tire might be a more suitable choice.
- Radial design for a smoother ride than bias-ply options
- Non-directional tread pattern for versatile traction
- 6-ply rated for decent puncture resistance
Pros: Very accessible option for budget-conscious buyers; Offers reasonable all-terrain performance; Radial construction provides a more comfortable ride than expected for the category
Cons: Durability may not match premium brands under heavy use; Less aggressive traction in deep mud compared to specialized tires
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between radial and bias-ply UTV tires?
In our research, we found that radial tires have plies running perpendicular to the tread, with an additional belt layer under the tread. This construction allows for more tread flexibility and a larger contact patch, leading to a smoother ride, better handling, and often longer tread life. Bias-ply tires, conversely, have plies crisscrossing at an angle, resulting in a stiffer sidewall and tread, which can offer better puncture resistance in some areas but typically a rougher ride and less consistent contact with the ground.
How does ply rating affect UTV tire performance?
Based on manufacturer specifications and industry standards, the ply rating indicates the tire’s strength and load-carrying capacity. A higher ply rating, such as 8-ply or 10-ply, generally means a more robust tire with greater resistance to punctures and sidewall damage, making it suitable for aggressive riding, heavy loads, or challenging terrain. However, higher ply tires can also be heavier and stiffer, potentially impacting ride comfort and requiring more power from the UTV.
What type of UTV tire is best for mud riding?
For mud riding, our evaluation indicates that tires with aggressive, widely spaced, and deep lugs are most effective. These designs allow the tire to dig into and self-clean from thick mud, maintaining traction. Often, these tires also feature reinforced sidewalls and shoulder lugs to provide additional grip when navigating ruts. Examples include the ITP Mega Mayhem, which is specifically engineered for severe mud conditions.
Are all-terrain UTV tires a good compromise?
Yes, in our comparison, all-terrain UTV tires are often an excellent compromise for riders who encounter a variety of conditions and do not specialize in extreme mud, rock, or sand. They feature a balanced tread pattern designed to offer good traction on hardpack, loose dirt, gravel, and light mud, while also providing a relatively smooth ride. While they may not excel in any single extreme condition, their versatility makes them a popular and practical choice for most recreational UTV owners.
How important is tire pressure for UTV tires?
Based on aggregated owner feedback and safety guidelines, maintaining correct tire pressure is critically important for UTV tires. Proper inflation ensures optimal performance, handling, and safety. Under-inflated tires can lead to premature wear, poor handling, and increased risk of bead separation, while over-inflated tires can reduce traction, create a harsh ride, and make the tire more susceptible to punctures. Always consult your UTV’s owner’s manual or the tire manufacturer’s recommendations for specific pressure guidelines.
Our Verdict
After extensive research and comparison, the Maxxis Bighorn 2.0 Radial Tire stands out as our top pick for the best overall UTV side by side tire, offering an exceptional balance of all-terrain performance, durability, and ride comfort. For riders who frequently tackle challenging mud and soft terrain, the ITP Mega Mayhem ATV/UTV Tire is our recommended runner-up, providing unmatched traction in those specific conditions.
Last reviewed and spec-checked: June 23, 2026. We re-check our picks and listings periodically.
