We researched and compared the top surfboard holders for car based on manufacturer specifications, published safety standards, and aggregated owner feedback. Our evaluation covers roof racks, soft racks, and tailgate pads to help you choose the right one for your vehicle and board type.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Thule Surf Pro Best Overall Fits up to 6 boards, lockable, fits most factory racks |
9.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Yakima Surflock 6 Runner Up Fits 6 boards, lockable, fits Yakima round bars |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
INNO Surf Carrier Best Value Fits 2 boards, soft pads, fits most crossbars |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Rhino-Rack Surfboard Carrier Best for Heavy Boards Fits 2 boards, heavy-duty, fits Rhino-Rack bars |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
FCS Soft Rack Best Soft Rack Fits 2 boards, no roof rack needed, foam pads |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Dakine Tailgate Pad Best for Trucks Fits 6 boards, truck tailgate, padded |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
SportRack Universal Surfboard Carrier Budget Pick Fits 2 boards, universal, foam blocks |
7.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Thule Surf Pro: Best Overall
The Thule Surf Pro is a premium roof-mounted surfboard carrier designed for serious surfers. In our evaluation, its padded cradles and adjustable straps provide a secure hold for up to six boards without damaging the fins or hull. The integrated locks add peace of mind when leaving boards unattended. Owner feedback consistently praises its robust construction and ease of use on factory crossbars.
However, this holder requires an existing roof rack system, which adds to the overall cost. If you don’t have crossbars or prefer a temporary solution, consider a soft rack instead. The Thule Surf Pro is best for surfers who already have a roof rack and want a permanent, high-security option.
- Holds up to 6 surfboards securely with padded cradles
- Integrated locks deter theft
- Tool-free installation on most factory roof racks
Pros: Excellent build quality and durability; Easy to load and secure boards
Cons: Requires existing roof rack crossbars
2. Yakima Surflock 6: Runner Up
The Yakima Surflock 6 is a close competitor to the Thule, offering similar capacity and security. We compared its locking mechanism and found it easy to operate, with knobs that tighten firmly. Owners report that it holds boards securely even at highway speeds. The adjustable cradles accommodate various board thicknesses.
Its main limitation is compatibility: it works best with Yakima crossbars, and using it with other brands may require additional adapters. If you have a Yakima rack, this is an excellent choice. Otherwise, the Thule offers broader compatibility out of the box.
- Carries up to 6 surfboards with adjustable cradles
- Locking knobs secure boards to the rack
- Compatible with Yakima round and aerodynamic bars
Pros: Sturdy and reliable for long trips; Cradles adjust for different board shapes
Cons: May not fit all non-Yakima crossbars without adapters
3. INNO Surf Carrier: Best Value
The INNO Surf Carrier is a budget-friendly option that still delivers reliable performance. In our research, its soft rubber cradles and adjustable straps hold boards firmly without scratching. Owners appreciate the straightforward installation and universal fit on most crossbars. It is a solid choice for surfers who only need to carry one or two boards.
However, the lower capacity and less robust locking mechanism may not suit those with multiple boards or high-security needs. If you carry more than two boards regularly, consider a higher-capacity model. The INNO is best for casual surfers or those on a budget.
- Carries up to 2 surfboards with soft rubber pads
- Universal fit for most roof rack crossbars
- Lightweight and easy to install
Pros: Affordable without sacrificing quality; Soft pads protect board finish
Cons: Lower capacity than premium models
4. Rhino-Rack Surfboard Carrier: Best for Heavy Boards
The Rhino-Rack Surfboard Carrier is built for durability, with a robust design that can handle heavier longboards. We examined its strap mechanism and found it reliable and easy to use. Owner feedback highlights its stability on rough roads. The padded cradles protect boards from scratches.
Its main drawback is that it is optimized for Rhino-Rack crossbars; using it with other racks may require adapters. If you have a Rhino-Rack system, this is a top pick. For universal use, other options offer better fit.
- Heavy-duty construction supports larger boards
- Padded cradles with anti-slip grip
- Easy to load with quick-release straps
Pros: Very durable and stable for heavy boards; Straps are easy to tighten and release
Cons: Best compatibility with Rhino-Rack crossbars
5. FCS Soft Rack: Best Soft Rack
The FCS Soft Rack is a convenient solution for surfers who don’t have a roof rack. It uses foam pads and straps that loop through the car’s doors to hold boards. In our evaluation, it is easy to install and remove, making it ideal for occasional use. Owners like its portability and low cost.
However, soft racks are inherently less secure than permanent roof racks, especially at highway speeds. The straps can loosen over time, requiring periodic checks. This rack is best for short trips and surfers who need a temporary, no-fuss setup. For regular long-distance travel, a hard rack is recommended.
- Carries up to 2 surfboards without roof rack
- Foam pads protect car roof and boards
- Quick to install and remove
Pros: No roof rack required, works on any car; Very affordable and portable
Cons: Less secure than hard racks at high speeds
6. Dakine Tailgate Pad: Best for Trucks
The Dakine Tailgate Pad is designed specifically for pickup trucks, covering the tailgate to protect both the truck and boards. We compared its padding and strap system, which secures boards vertically. Owners appreciate the ease of loading and unloading boards from the bed. It is a great option for truck owners who carry boards frequently.
Its main limitation is that it only works on trucks with a tailgate. If you drive an SUV or car, this is not suitable. Additionally, boards may be exposed to road debris. For truck owners, it is a convenient and protective solution.
- Padded tailgate pad protects boards and truck
- Holds up to 6 boards with integrated straps
- Easy to install over tailgate
Pros: Protects tailgate from scratches; Good for carrying multiple boards
Cons: Limited to pickup trucks only
7. SportRack Universal Surfboard Carrier: Budget Pick
The SportRack Universal Surfboard Carrier is the most affordable option in our comparison. It uses foam blocks and straps to secure boards to existing crossbars. In our research, it performs adequately for light, occasional use. Owners on a budget find it acceptable for short trips.
However, the materials and build quality are noticeably lower than other picks. The straps may fray over time, and the foam can compress. If you surf frequently or carry valuable boards, invest in a higher-quality model. This carrier is best for very occasional use or as a temporary solution.
- Carries up to 2 surfboards with foam blocks
- Universal fit with adjustable straps
- Lowest cost option
Pros: Very inexpensive; Works on most vehicles with roof racks
Cons: Less durable materials and hardware
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a surfboard holder on a car without roof rails?
Yes, soft racks like the FCS Soft Rack are designed for cars without roof rails. They use straps that loop through the door frames and foam pads to protect the roof. However, they are less secure than hard racks and require periodic tightening during long trips.
How many surfboards can a roof rack hold?
Most roof-mounted carriers hold between 2 and 6 boards, depending on the model. The Thule Surf Pro and Yakima Surflock 6 can carry up to 6 boards, while smaller carriers like the INNO hold 2. Always check the manufacturer’s weight and size limits.
Do surfboard holders fit all roof rack crossbars?
Many holders are designed to fit factory and aftermarket crossbars, but compatibility varies. Brands like Thule and Yakima often require their own crossbars or adapters. Always check the product specifications for crossbar shape and size compatibility before purchasing.
Are locking surfboard carriers worth it?
Locking carriers add security against theft, which is valuable if you leave boards unattended. Models like the Thule Surf Pro and Yakima Surflock 6 include locks. For occasional use or short stops, non-locking carriers may suffice, but locks provide peace of mind.
Can I use a tailgate pad for surfboards on an SUV?
Tailgate pads are designed specifically for pickup trucks with drop-down tailgates. They do not fit SUVs or cars. For those vehicles, roof racks or soft racks are the appropriate choices.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing, the Thule Surf Pro earns our top recommendation for its excellent build quality, security features, and ease of use. The Yakima Surflock 6 is a close runner-up, especially for Yakima rack owners. For budget-conscious surfers, the INNO Surf Carrier offers great value without compromising essential features.
