After researching dozens of spare tire storage bags, comparing manufacturer specifications, owner feedback, and industry standards for weather resistance and material durability, we selected the top seven. Our evaluation focused on fit for common tire sizes, waterproofing, abrasion resistance, and ease of use. Whether you need a heavy-duty cover for a lifted truck or a compact bag for a sedan spare, this guide will help you choose the right one for your needs and budget.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
Covercraft TYVEK Spare Tire Cover Best Overall Fits up to 35-inch tires; Tyvek material |
9.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Dee Zee DZ8310 Heavy Duty Spare Tire Cover Runner Up Fits up to 37-inch tires; 600D PVC-backed polyester |
8.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Tire Gate TG-100 Spare Tire Bag Best for Compact Spares Fits compact spares up to 27 inches; 420D nylon |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Rugged Ridge 13360.10 Spare Tire Cover Best for Jeeps Fits 31-33 inch tires; heavy-duty vinyl |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Leader Accessories Spare Tire Cover Best Value Fits up to 31-inch tires; polyester with PVC coating |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Emission Test Products Spare Tire Bag Best Heavy-Duty Fits up to 35-inch tires; 900D polyester with PVC |
7.5 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Truck Covers USA Spare Tire Cover Best for Full-Size Trucks Fits 33-37 inch tires; marine-grade vinyl |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Covercraft TYVEK Spare Tire Cover: Best Overall
The Covercraft TYVEK Spare Tire Cover is our top pick because it balances toughness and weight exceptionally well. Made from DuPont Tyvek, it resists punctures, tears, and UV degradation far better than standard polyester covers. In our evaluation based on owner feedback and the spec sheet, it held up well against highway debris and prolonged sun exposure. The elastic hem and drawstring keep it secure even at freeway speeds, and a reflective strip adds a safety margin for roadside changes.
However, Tyvek is breathable, not waterproof. In sustained downpours, moisture can wick through. If you live in a very rainy climate or submerge the tire, consider a vinyl cover instead. Also, it fits up to 35-inch tires; for larger off-road tires, you may need a different option. Overall, it is a smart choice for daily drivers and overlanders who prioritize durability over absolute waterproofing.
- Tyvek material resists tears, punctures, and UV damage
- Elastic hem and drawstring closure for a snug fit
- Reflective stripe for low-light visibility
Pros: Extremely durable against abrasion and weather; Lightweight and easy to install
Cons: Not fully waterproof in heavy rain
2. Dee Zee DZ8310 Heavy Duty Spare Tire Cover: Runner Up
The Dee Zee DZ8310 is a heavy-duty alternative for owners of larger trucks and SUVs. Its 600D polyester fabric with PVC coating provides superior water repellency compared to breathable materials. Owner feedback consistently praises its ability to keep tires dry through rain and snow. The adjustable drawstring and locking strap hold it firmly in place, even on rough terrain.
On the downside, the PVC backing makes it heavier and less packable. If you need to stow the cover when not in use, it takes up more space. It also lacks a reflective element, so safety at night is a minor concern. This bag is best for those who prioritize water protection above all else and have a permanent spare tire mount.
- 600D polyester with PVC backing for weather resistance
- Adjustable drawstring with locking strap
- UV-treated to prevent fading and cracking
Pros: Excellent water resistance; Fits very large tires up to 37 inches
Cons: Bulkier and heavier than Tyvek covers
3. Tire Gate TG-100 Spare Tire Bag: Best for Compact Spares
For drivers with a compact spare tire stored in the trunk, the Tire Gate TG-100 is a practical and economical choice. It is made from 420D nylon with a water-resistant coating, sufficient for occasional moisture exposure. The zippered closure with a Velcro flap keeps the tire clean and dry. Owner feedback highlights its convenience for organizing the trunk and preventing dirt from spreading.
However, this bag is not intended for long-term outdoor exposure. The nylon fabric is less abrasion-resistant, and the zipper is a potential weak point. If you have a full-size spare or mount the tire on a rear carrier, look for a more robust option. It is ideal for city drivers who want a simple, budget-friendly storage solution for a compact spare.
- Lightweight 420D nylon with water-resistant coating
- Zippered closure with Velcro flap
- Carrying handle for easy transport
Pros: Very affordable; Compact and easy to store in trunk
Cons: Not as durable as heavy-duty covers; Zipper may fail with heavy use
4. Rugged Ridge 13360.10 Spare Tire Cover: Best for Jeeps
The Rugged Ridge 13360.10 is a dedicated cover for Jeep Wranglers with 31 to 33-inch tires. It is made from heavy-duty vinyl that provides complete waterproofing. Owner feedback from off-road enthusiasts confirms it holds up well against mud and rain. The elastic cord and strap keep it in place during trail rides.
That said, vinyl becomes stiff and may crack in very low temperatures. It also only fits a narrow tire size range, so it is not versatile for other vehicles. If you own a Jeep and want a cover that matches the factory spare mount, this is a solid choice. For other vehicles or larger tires, look elsewhere.
- Vinyl construction with stitched seams
- Fits standard Jeep Wrangler spare tire sizes
- Elastic cord and strap for secure fit
Pros: Good fit for Jeep Wrangler spares; Vinyl is fully waterproof
Cons: Vinyl can crack in extreme cold; Limited size range
5. Leader Accessories Spare Tire Cover: Best Value
The Leader Accessories Spare Tire Cover is a budget-friendly option for those who need basic protection for a spare tire stored on a rear mount or in a garage. It features a polyester shell with a PVC coating that offers decent water resistance. The elastic cord makes installation quick. Owner feedback notes it works well for occasional use and keeps dust and light rain off the tire.
However, the PVC coating can deteriorate with prolonged sun exposure, and the fabric is thinner than premium covers. It is not recommended for extreme weather or off-road use. If you need a temporary or low-cost cover for a spare tire that is not exposed to harsh conditions, this is a fine choice. But for long-term outdoor storage, invest in a more durable product.
- Polyester fabric with PVC coating
- Elastic cord for quick installation
- Available in multiple solid colors
Pros: Very low price point; Lightweight and easy to install
Cons: PVC coating may peel over time; Not as durable as premium covers
6. Emission Test Products Spare Tire Bag: Best Heavy-Duty
The Emission Test Products Spare Tire Bag is built for extreme durability. Its 900D polyester with PVC backing is among the thickest we evaluated. Owner feedback from truck and RV owners indicates it withstands highway speeds and rough roads without tearing. Double-stitched seams and reinforced grommets add to its longevity.
On the downside, this bag is heavy and takes up significant space when not in use. It also lacks a reflective element, so safety at night is a concern. Additionally, it is less commonly stocked, so availability may be spotty. This bag is best for those who need maximum abrasion resistance for a permanently mounted spare tire, especially on a truck or trailer. For lighter use, it may be overkill.
- 900D polyester with PVC backing
- Double-stitched seams and reinforced grommets
- Adjustable drawstring with locking buckle
Pros: Very thick and tough material; Reinforced stress points
Cons: Heavy and bulky; Limited availability
7. Truck Covers USA Spare Tire Cover: Best for Full-Size Trucks
The Truck Covers USA Spare Tire Cover is designed for full-size trucks with large tires. Its marine-grade vinyl provides complete waterproofing and UV resistance, making it suitable for long-term outdoor storage. Owner feedback from truck owners highlights that it fits well over 35-inch tires and stays secure with elastic cord and tie-downs.
However, the non-breathable vinyl can trap moisture between the cover and tire, potentially leading to mildew or corrosion if the tire is not completely dry before installation. It is also one of the more expensive options. This cover is ideal for trucks that see heavy rain or sun exposure, but you must ensure the tire is dry before covering. For drier climates, a breathable cover may be a better choice.
- Marine-grade vinyl for full waterproofing
- Elastic cord and tie-down straps
- UV-resistant coating
Pros: Completely waterproof; UV protection prevents fading
Cons: Expensive; Not breathable, can trap moisture
Frequently Asked Questions
What size spare tire storage bag do I need?
Measure your tire’s diameter and width. Most bags specify a range of tire sizes. For example, a bag that fits up to 35 inches will accommodate most SUV and light truck spares. Compact spares usually require a smaller bag around 27 inches. Always check the manufacturer’s fitment guide before purchasing.
Are spare tire storage bags waterproof?
It depends on the material. Vinyl and PVC-coated bags offer full waterproofing, but they are not breathable, which can trap moisture. Tyvek and uncoated nylon are water-resistant but not fully waterproof. For long-term outdoor storage in wet climates, a waterproof bag is recommended, but ensure the tire is dry before covering.
Can I use a spare tire storage bag for a tire mounted on a rear carrier?
Yes, many bags are designed for both trunk storage and exterior mounting. Look for bags with secure closures like drawstrings with locking straps or elastic hems. For rear carriers, ensure the bag fits snugly and does not flap at highway speeds. Reflective elements are a plus for visibility.
How do I clean and maintain my spare tire storage bag?
Most bags can be wiped clean with a mild soap and water solution. Avoid harsh chemicals that may degrade the coating. For vinyl bags, use a vinyl protectant to prevent cracking. Store the bag in a cool, dry place when not in use to extend its lifespan.
Will a spare tire storage bag protect against UV damage?
Many bags are treated with UV inhibitors or made from UV-resistant materials like Tyvek or marine-grade vinyl. These help prevent the tire rubber from drying out and cracking due to sun exposure. Check the product specifications for UV protection claims.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing seven of the best spare tire storage bags, the Covercraft TYVEK Spare Tire Cover stands out as our top pick for its exceptional durability, lightweight design, and reflective safety feature. For those who need maximum water protection, the Dee Zee DZ8310 Heavy Duty Spare Tire Cover is a strong runner-up with its PVC-backed polyester and large size range. Choose the Covercraft for all-around performance, or the Dee Zee if you prioritize waterproofing above all else.
Last reviewed and spec-checked: May 10, 2026. We re-check our picks and listings periodically.
