After researching and comparing the most popular soft surf racks on the market, we evaluated each based on manufacturer specifications, published safety standards, and aggregated owner feedback. These foam-and-strap racks offer a budget-friendly way to carry surfboards without a permanent roof rack, but not all are created equal. Our guide highlights real strengths and limitations to help you choose the right one for your vehicle and boards.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
Thule Surfboard Carrier 810 Best Overall Fits vehicles with or without factory racks; 2-board capacity; 72-inch straps |
9.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Yakima SurfRack Runner Up Fits most vehicles with or without racks; holds up to 2 boards; 15 ft straps |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Boardworks Surf Rack Pads Best Value Universal foam blocks; 2-board capacity; 12 ft straps |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
FCS Soft Rack Premium Pick Fits vehicles with or without racks; holds up to 3 boards; 15 ft straps |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Crescent Moon Surf Rack Compact Design Fits most cars; holds 1-2 boards; 10 ft straps |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
SURFCO Soft Roof Rack Budget Friendly Universal fit; holds 2 boards; 12 ft cam straps |
7.5 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Rage Powersports Surf Rack Versatile Fit Fits vehicles with or without racks; holds 2 boards; 14 ft straps |
7.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Thule Surfboard Carrier 810: Best Overall
In our evaluation, the Thule Surfboard Carrier 810 stands out for its robust construction and thoughtful design. The foam blocks are dense and contoured to fit various roof shapes, and the straps are wide with padded handles to avoid scratching. Owner feedback consistently praises its stability at highway speeds, and the optional lock kit adds peace of mind. However, the price is significantly higher than entry-level options, and the straps can be slightly short for oversized SUVs or vans.
This rack is ideal for surfers who want a premium, secure solution and plan to use it frequently. If you only carry boards occasionally or need to transport multiple boards (more than two), you might be better served by a dedicated roof rack system or a cheaper alternative.
- Padded foam blocks with non-slip base protect car roof and boards
- Integrated locking straps (sold separately) for added security
- Quick-install cam buckle system with padded handles
Pros: Excellent build quality and padding; Works on most vehicles including those with raised rails
Cons: Higher price point compared to basic foam pads
2. Yakima SurfRack: Runner Up
We compared the Yakima SurfRack and found it a close second to Thule. The foam is thick and resilient, and the included tie-down loops are a nice touch for extra security. Based on owner feedback, it fits a wide range of vehicles securely, and the reflective straps are a safety bonus. However, some users report that the straps may loosen under extreme heat or prolonged sun exposure, requiring occasional re-tightening.
This is a solid choice for most surfers who want a reliable, well-known brand without paying top dollar. If you live in a very hot climate or frequently drive long distances, you might prefer the Thule’s more secure buckle system.
- Thick EVA foam blocks with anti-slip texture
- Includes tie-down loops for bow/stern lines
- Straps have reflective stitching for visibility
Pros: Easy to install and adjust; Durable foam that holds shape over time
Cons: Straps can loosen slightly in very hot weather
3. Boardworks Surf Rack Pads: Best Value
After researching budget options, the Boardworks Surf Rack Pads offer the best value for casual surfers. The foam is adequate for occasional use, and the ratchet straps are easy to tighten. Owner feedback highlights the low price and included storage bag as major pluses. However, the foam is less dense than premium brands, and some users report it flattening after a season of regular use.
This set is perfect for someone who needs a temporary or infrequent solution, like a road trip or occasional weekend surf. If you plan to carry boards daily or over long distances, investing in a higher-end rack will provide better long-term performance and safety.
- Lightweight foam pads with non-marring base
- Includes four 12-foot ratchet straps
- Compact storage bag included
Pros: Very affordable; Works on almost any vehicle
Cons: Foam may compress over time with heavy use
4. FCS Soft Rack: Premium Pick
The FCS Soft Rack is a premium option that can hold up to three boards, which is rare among soft racks. In our evaluation, the UV-resistant foam and secure locking mechanism (lock optional) make it appealing for frequent users. Owner feedback confirms it holds boards securely at speed, but the high price puts it in competition with entry-level hard racks. Some users also find the straps a bit stiff initially.
This rack is best for surfers who own multiple boards and want a durable, high-capacity soft rack. If you only carry one or two boards, a less expensive two-board rack will suffice and save money.
- High-density foam with UV-resistant coating
- Integrated locking mechanism (lock sold separately)
- Straps with soft touch handles
Pros: Can carry up to 3 boards; UV-resistant foam lasts longer in sun
Cons: Expensive for a soft rack
5. Crescent Moon Surf Rack: Compact Design
We looked at the Crescent Moon Surf Rack for its compact design. The small foam blocks are easy to store in a trunk, and the straps are sufficient for short trips. However, based on owner feedback, the smaller blocks can shift on vehicles with curved or wide roofs, and the straps are shorter than average, limiting fit on larger vehicles.
This rack is a good choice for compact cars or for surfers with limited storage space. If you drive an SUV or full-size truck, the smaller blocks may not provide enough stability, and you should consider a rack with larger pads.
- Small foam blocks for compact storage
- Includes anti-slip pads on the base
- Lightweight and portable
Pros: Very compact when stored; Easy to install
Cons: Foam blocks are smaller, less stable on wide roofs
6. SURFCO Soft Roof Rack: Budget Friendly
The SURFCO Soft Roof Rack is one of the most affordable options we researched. It includes a bag and basic straps, making it a tempting entry-level choice. However, owner feedback indicates that the foam compresses after a few uses, and the plastic buckles are not as durable as metal ones. Some users reported straps loosening during long drives.
This rack is suitable for very occasional use, such as a single trip or for carrying a soft-top board. For regular use or heavier boards, the risk of strap failure or foam degradation makes it a less safe choice, and we recommend spending a bit more for a more reliable product.
- Low-cost foam pads
- Includes 4 cam straps with plastic buckles
- Carrying bag included
Pros: Very inexpensive; Comes with storage bag
Cons: Foam may compress easily; Buckles are plastic and can break under high tension
7. Rage Powersports Surf Rack: Versatile Fit
The Rage Powersports Surf Rack is designed to be versatile, with cutouts that fit over existing roof rack bars if desired. In our comparison, the metal hooks are a plus, but the foam blocks lack a non-slip base, leading to reports of sliding on vehicles with smooth, curved roofs. Owner feedback also mentions that the installation instructions are confusing, causing some to struggle with proper setup.
This rack may work for drivers with factory roof racks who want a soft option, but for most users, the sliding issue is a significant drawback. We recommend skipping this if you have a modern car with a sleek roofline; instead, choose a rack with a proven non-slip design.
- Foam blocks with cutouts for roof rack bars
- Straps with metal hooks
- Reflective strips on straps
Pros: Works with or without existing roof racks; Metal hooks are sturdy
Cons: Foam can slide on smooth roofs; Instructions are unclear
Frequently Asked Questions
Are soft surf racks safe for highway driving?
Soft surf racks can be safe for highway driving if installed correctly and used within their weight limits. We recommend checking the straps periodically during long trips, as wind and vibration can cause slight loosening. Always use bow and stern lines for added security, especially for longer boards or higher speeds.
Will a soft surf rack damage my car's paint?
Most quality soft racks use foam pads with non-abrasive bases to prevent scratching. However, dirt or grit trapped between the foam and roof can cause micro-scratches. We advise cleaning both the roof and the foam pads before each use, and avoiding dragging straps across the paint.
How many boards can a soft surf rack carry?
Most soft racks are designed for 1-2 boards, though some premium models can hold up to 3. Stacking more than 2 boards can compromise stability and increase the risk of damage. Always follow the manufacturer’s recommended capacity.
Can I use a soft surf rack on a car with a sunroof?
Yes, soft racks can be used on cars with sunroofs, but be cautious not to block the sunroof mechanism or place excessive pressure on the glass. Some users report that the foam pads can obstruct the sunroof opening, so check clearance before installing.
How do I prevent straps from flapping and making noise?
After tightening, tuck any excess strap length under the foam pads or secure them with a rubber band. Many racks include strap keepers or velcro wraps. If not, you can use zip ties or tape to reduce wind noise.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing the top soft surf racks, we recommend the Thule Surfboard Carrier 810 for its superior build quality, safety features, and ease of use. For a more budget-friendly option that still performs well, the Boardworks Surf Rack Pads offers excellent value for occasional surfers.
