We researched and compared the top side by side winches on the market using manufacturer specifications, industry safety standards (SAE J706, ANSI/ITSDF B56.11.6), and aggregated owner feedback from forums and review sites. Our evaluation focuses on real-world performance, durability, ease of installation, and safety features to help you choose the best winch for your UTV.
Whether you need a winch for trail recovery, work tasks, or extreme off-roading, we break down each model’s strengths and weaknesses. Note that no product is perfect, and we highlight limitations to help you avoid a poor purchase.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
WARN VRX 45 Top Pick 4,500 lb capacity, synthetic rope, IP68 waterproof, 3-stage planetary gear train |
9 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Superwinch SXTR 4500 Runner Up 4,500 lb capacity, steel cable, 1.5 hp motor, 3-stage planetary gearing |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Smittybilt XRC Gen3 4.5K Best Value 4,500 lb capacity, synthetic rope, IP67 waterproof, 2.0 hp motor |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
KFI Products Winch Mount and 4500 lb Winch Combo Best Combo 4,500 lb capacity, steel cable, includes winch plate mount, 1.3 hp motor |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Badland ZXR 3500 Budget Pick 3,500 lb capacity, steel cable, 0.8 hp motor, wired remote only |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Rough Country Pro Series 4500 Durable Choice 4,500 lb capacity, synthetic rope, IP68 waterproof, 1.8 hp motor |
8.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Viper Elite 4500 Synthetic Rope Specialist 4,500 lb capacity, synthetic rope, 1.5 hp motor, aluminum housing |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. WARN VRX 45: Top Pick
We evaluated the WARN VRX 45 against the industry’s toughest standards. Its synthetic rope and IP68 rating make it a top choice for riders who frequently encounter deep mud or water. Owner feedback consistently praises its reliability, though some note the rope can fray if dragged over sharp rocks without a protection sleeve.
The main drawback is cost: it’s significantly more expensive than many 4,500 lb winches. If you’re on a tight budget or only need occasional light recovery, a less expensive option may suffice. However, for serious off-roaders who demand durability and safety, this winch is worth the investment.
- Synthetic rope is lighter and safer than steel, reducing risk of whiplash if snapped.
- IP68 waterproof rating ensures reliable operation in mud and water crossings.
- 3-stage planetary gear train provides smooth, powerful pulling with minimal amp draw.
Pros: Excellent corrosion resistance from sealed housing and stainless steel hardware.; Wireless remote standard, with wired backup included.
Cons: Premium price compared to similar-capacity competitors.
2. Superwinch SXTR 4500: Runner Up
We compared the Superwinch SXTR 4500’s steel cable construction to synthetic alternatives and found it excels in rocky environments where abrasion is a concern. Spec sheets show a 1.5 hp motor that draws moderate amps, and owner feedback confirms consistent performance even under heavy loads.
The steel cable is a double-edged sword: it’s tougher but poses a safety risk if it fails. We recommend using a winch damper. Also, the winch lacks a wireless remote (wired only), which some users find inconvenient. If you prioritize abrasion resistance over convenience, this is a solid choice.
- Steel cable offers superior abrasion resistance for rocky terrain.
- Compact and lightweight design at just 28 lbs fits most UTV bumpers.
- Rugged aluminum housing with corrosion-resistant finish.
Pros: Proven reliability with decades of owner feedback.; Easy to service with readily available parts.
Cons: Steel cable can be dangerous if it snaps; requires a damper blanket.
3. Smittybilt XRC Gen3 4.5K: Best Value
We analyzed the Smittybilt XRC Gen3 4.5K’s value proposition. It offers synthetic rope and a waterproof rating at a price point well below WARN and Superwinch. Based on owner feedback, it performs well for most recovery scenarios, though a few users noted the remote can be finicky in cold weather.
The IP67 rating means it can handle splashes and brief submersion, but not prolonged underwater use. If you frequently cross deep water, consider a winch with IP68. For most trail riders, this is a great balance of cost and capability.
- Synthetic rope with hook and safety thimble for reduced weight.
- IP67 rating protects against dust and temporary submersion.
- Includes wireless remote and wired controller.
Pros: Very competitive price for a synthetic rope winch.; Strong pulling power with 2.0 hp motor.
Cons: Some owners report intermittent remote connection issues.
4. KFI Products Winch Mount and 4500 lb Winch Combo: Best Combo
We evaluated the KFI combo as a convenient package for first-time buyers. The included winch plate simplifies installation, and spec sheets indicate a 1.3 hp motor that handles typical recovery. Owner feedback is positive for ease of installation, but some note the cable is a bit short for certain anchor points.
The main limitation is the steel cable’s safety risk and the fact that the winch itself is less powerful than some competitors. If you anticipate heavy use or need synthetic rope, consider a different model. For occasional use and easy mounting, this combo works well.
- Comes with a winch plate designed to fit many Polaris, Can-Am, and Yamaha models.
- Steel cable with roller fairlead for reduced friction.
- Two-year limited warranty.
Pros: All-in-one solution saves installation guesswork.; Good value for a complete package.
Cons: Winch plate may not fit aftermarket bumpers; check compatibility.
5. Badland ZXR 3500: Budget Pick
We assessed the Badland ZXR 3500 against its intended use: light-duty recovery for small UTVs. Based on owner feedback, it works well for pulling a stuck machine out of mud or snow, but struggles with heavier loads. The 0.8 hp motor is underpowered for anything beyond 3,000 lbs.
Durability is a concern: some users report the steel cable kinking easily and the housing showing rust after a season. We recommend this only if you have a lightweight side by side and infrequent recovery needs. For serious off-roading, invest in a higher-capacity winch.
- Lowest price among reputable brands for light-duty use.
- Compact size fits small UTVs like Polaris RZR 170.
- Includes roller fairlead and mounting hardware.
Pros: Very affordable for budget-conscious buyers.; Lightweight at 22 lbs.
Cons: Limited capacity; not suitable for larger side by sides or heavy recovery.
6. Rough Country Pro Series 4500: Durable Choice
We compared the Rough Country Pro Series 4500’s specifications to other IP68-rated winches and found its durability features stand out. The sealed solenoid and motor are designed to prevent water ingress, and owner feedback confirms it survives repeated submersion. The synthetic rope includes a sleeve that helps protect against fraying.
The main downside is weight; at 35 lbs, it may affect front-end handling on lighter UTVs. Also, the wireless remote range is shorter than some (about 50 feet). If you prioritize toughness and water resistance, this is a strong contender.
- IP68 rating with sealed solenoid and motor for deep water crossings.
- Synthetic rope with protective sleeve to reduce abrasion.
- 3-stage planetary gear train for efficient power transfer.
Pros: Very durable build with high waterproof rating.; Smooth and quiet operation.
Cons: Heavier than competitors at 35 lbs.
7. Viper Elite 4500: Synthetic Rope Specialist
We looked at the Viper Elite 4500 as a budget-friendly synthetic rope option. Specs show a 1.5 hp motor and aluminum housing, but aggregated owner feedback reveals mixed reliability. Several users experienced motor failure after a few dozen pulls, and the warranty process was cited as slow.
We recommend this only for very light, occasional use. If you rely on your winch for regular recovery, the risk of failure is too high. A more reliable synthetic rope winch like the WARN VRX 45 is a better long-term investment.
- Lightweight synthetic rope reduces injury risk.
- Aluminum housing resists corrosion.
- Includes wireless remote and wired controller.
Pros: Synthetic rope is safer than steel.; Affordable price point for synthetic rope.
Cons: Durability concerns: some owners report motor burnout after heavy use.
Frequently Asked Questions
What capacity winch do I need for my side by side?
We recommend a winch with a rated line pull at least 1.5 times the vehicle’s gross weight. For most UTVs (1,500-2,500 lbs), a 3,500-4,500 lb winch is sufficient. Heavier machines or those used for plowing may need a 5,000 lb unit.
Should I choose synthetic rope or steel cable?
Synthetic rope is lighter, safer (no whiplash if snapped), and easier to handle, but it abrades more easily on rocks. Steel cable is more abrasion-resistant but poses a safety risk and is heavier. For most trail riding, synthetic is preferred; for rocky terrain, steel may be better.
Are waterproof ratings important for a winch?
Yes, especially if you ride in mud, water, or snow. IP67 protects against temporary submersion up to 1 meter for 30 minutes; IP68 is better for deeper or prolonged exposure. A non-waterproof winch can fail after a single deep water crossing.
Do I need a winch plate or mount?
Most UTVs require a specific winch plate or mount to attach the winch securely. Some winches come with a universal plate, but many do not. Check your vehicle’s compatibility before purchasing. KFI’s combo includes a plate, which simplifies installation.
Can I install a winch myself?
Yes, with basic mechanical skills and tools. Most winches include wiring and mounting hardware. However, you may need to drill mounting holes or splice into the battery. If you’re uncomfortable, professional installation is recommended to ensure safe electrical connections.
Our Verdict
After comparing specifications, safety standards, and owner feedback, our top pick is the WARN VRX 45 for its exceptional durability, IP68 waterproofing, and synthetic rope safety. For a more budget-friendly option with solid performance, the Superwinch SXTR 4500 is our runner up, especially for rocky terrain where steel cable is beneficial.
