We researched, compared, and evaluated the most popular luggage carriers for SUVs using manufacturer specifications, industry safety standards, and aggregated owner feedback. Our goal is to help you choose a carrier that fits your vehicle, budget, and travel needs without guesswork.
We considered factors like aerodynamics, weight capacity, ease of installation, security features, and real-world durability reported by owners. The following seven products represent the best options in various categories, from hard-shell roof boxes to soft cargo bags and hitch-mounted baskets.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
Thule Motion XT L Best Overall Roof Box 16 cu ft capacity, 110 lb max load, fits vehicles with or without roof rails |
9.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Yakima SkyBox 16 Runner Up Roof Box 16 cu ft capacity, 110 lb max load, fits most factory racks and crossbars |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Rightline Gear SUV Cargo Carrier Best Soft Cargo Bag 15 cu ft capacity, 110 lb max load, weatherproof 600D polyester with PVC coating |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Curt 18151 Hitch Cargo Carrier Best Hitch-Mounted Platform 500 lb capacity, 60 x 20 inch platform, fits 2-inch receiver hitch |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
SportRack Vista XL Rear Mount Cargo Box Best Rear-Mounted Box 11 cu ft capacity, 100 lb max load, attaches to most rear-mounted spare tire carriers or hatch |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Thule Caprock 3-Pair Ski Carrier Best for Skis and Snowboards Holds up to 3 pairs of skis or 2 snowboards, attaches to roof racks with T-track or round bars |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Goplus 2-Person Roof Top Tent Best Multi-Function Carrier/Tent 66 x 50 x 48 inches when open, 150 lb weight, fits most roof racks with crossbars |
7.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Thule Motion XT L: Best Overall Roof Box
The Thule Motion XT L is a top-tier roof box that we found consistently praised by owners for its robust construction and user-friendly features. It offers dual-side opening, which is a game-changer when loading from either side of the SUV. The PowerClick mounting system includes a torque indicator that clicks when the correct tightness is reached, reducing the risk of improper installation. Based on spec sheets, it has a 110 lb capacity and a 16 cubic foot volume, suitable for a family of four on a week-long trip.
However, the Thule Motion XT L comes at a significant investment, and its value proposition is lower for those who only use a cargo box occasionally. Owners have noted that the glossy finish can scratch over time if not careful. If you are on a tight budget or need a carrier for infrequent use, a soft cargo bag or a more affordable hard shell may be a better fit.
- Dual-side opening for easy access from either side of the vehicle
- Aerodynamic design reduces wind noise and drag
- PowerClick quick-mount system with torque indicator for secure installation
Pros: Excellent build quality and weather sealing; Low profile fits in most garages
Cons: Premium price point may not suit all budgets
2. Yakima SkyBox 16: Runner Up Roof Box
The Yakima SkyBox 16 is a strong competitor, offering similar capacity and weight limits to the Thule Motion XT L. We evaluated its HD T-slots, which allow users to mount additional accessories like bike racks directly onto the box, a feature not found on all models. The centralized locking system is convenient, and owner feedback indicates the shell holds up well against UV and impacts.
One real limitation is its weight: at around 50 lbs, it can be cumbersome to mount on a tall SUV without assistance. Also, the SkyBox 16 is not compatible with all roof rack systems, so check fitment first. If you have a shorter vehicle or plan to carry skis, this is a great choice, but those with height restrictions may prefer a lighter option.
- HD T-slots for easy accessory mounting (bike racks, etc.)
- Centralized locking system with one key for all locks
- Slightly longer design fits skis up to 175 cm
Pros: Versatile T-slot system for adding other gear; Strong, durable shell with good security
Cons: Can be heavy to lift onto taller SUVs
3. Rightline Gear SUV Cargo Carrier: Best Soft Cargo Bag
The Rightline Gear SUV Cargo Carrier is our top pick for a soft-sided cargo bag. We researched owner feedback extensively, and many appreciate its ease of use: simply place the bag on your roof, load gear, and cinch down the straps. It has a 15 cu ft capacity and a 110 lb weight limit, matching many hard boxes. The 600D polyester with PVC coating provides good weather resistance, but it is not fully waterproof. In prolonged downpours, moisture can seep through seams.
Based on our evaluation, the main drawback is that it can flap in the wind if not tightened properly, and some owners reported straps loosening on long drives. It also does not offer the theft protection of a hard shell. If you need a low-cost, temporary solution for occasional trips and you don’t mind checking and retightening straps, this is a solid choice. For frequent use or long-distance travel, a hard shell may be more reliable.
- Folds flat when not in use for easy storage
- Includes anti-slip pads and tie-down straps for secure mounting
- Reflective safety stripes for visibility
Pros: Excellent value for budget-conscious buyers; Easy to install and remove without tools
Cons: Not waterproof; only weather-resistant in heavy rain
4. Curt 18151 Hitch Cargo Carrier: Best Hitch-Mounted Platform
The Curt 18151 is a hitch-mounted cargo carrier that we found to be a robust solution for heavy or bulky items. With a 500 lb capacity, it can handle coolers, camping gear, or even a motorcycle. The folded sides provide a lip to keep items from sliding off, and the powder coat resists rust. Owner feedback generally highlights its sturdiness and ease of assembly.
However, our evaluation noted that it adds significant length to the vehicle, which can make parking difficult and may obstruct the rear view and backup camera. It also reduces departure angle, which could be an issue off-road. Additionally, hitch carriers can affect rear sensor operation. If you frequently carry heavy loads and have a 2-inch hitch, this is a great option. For those who prioritize aerodynamics or need to access the trunk often, a roof box might be better.
- Heavy-duty steel construction with black powder coat finish
- Folded sides for added security and easy tie-down points
- Includes a 2-inch hitch pin and clip
Pros: Very high weight capacity compared to roof boxes; No roof clearance concerns; easy to access gear
Cons: May block rear view and backup camera
5. SportRack Vista XL Rear Mount Cargo Box: Best Rear-Mounted Box
The SportRack Vista XL is a rear-mounted cargo box designed for SUVs with a spare tire carrier or hatch mount. We evaluated its convenience: it does not block the rear hatch completely, and it can be folded flat when empty. Owner feedback indicates it is easy to install and provides decent weather protection for soft bags.
Our research shows that the main limitation is its capacity: only 11 cu ft and 100 lb limit, which is less than most roof boxes. Additionally, it can sway on rough roads if not strapped tightly, and some owners reported the mounting straps loosening over time. If you need a small, accessible carrier for light gear and you have a rear spare tire, this is a viable option. For heavier or larger loads, a roof box or hitch carrier is better.
- Allows access to rear hatch without removing the box
- Folds flat for storage when not in use
- UV-protected fabric with zippered opening
Pros: Does not affect roof rack or fuel economy as much as roof boxes; Easy to load and unload from ground level
Cons: Limited capacity and weight limit
6. Thule Caprock 3-Pair Ski Carrier: Best for Skis and Snowboards
The Thule Caprock is a dedicated ski and snowboard carrier, not a general luggage carrier. We included it because many SUV owners need to transport winter sports equipment. It holds up to 3 pairs of skis or 2 snowboards, and it locks to your roof rack. Owner feedback praises its ease of use and secure hold.
However, its utility is narrow: it cannot carry suitcases or bulky cargo. It also requires a roof rack system and is relatively expensive for what it does. If you only need to transport skis or snowboards and have a roof rack, this is a great specialized tool. For general luggage, look at a cargo box or bag.
- Lockable with included Thule One-Key system
- Padded arms protect equipment
- Aerodynamic design reduces wind noise
Pros: Specifically designed for winter sports gear; Easy to load and secure
Cons: Very limited use case; not a general luggage carrier
7. Goplus 2-Person Roof Top Tent: Best Multi-Function Carrier/Tent
The Goplus 2-Person Roof Top Tent is a niche product that serves as both a cargo carrier and a tent. When closed, it can store gear; when opened, it becomes a sleeping area for two. We researched owner feedback, which highlights its convenience for camping trips but also notes its bulk and weight (150 lbs). It requires a sturdy roof rack and can be difficult to install without help.
Our evaluation found that its primary limitation is that it is not a dedicated luggage carrier: it is heavy, reduces fuel economy, and the storage space is limited when the tent is closed. It also takes time to set up and break down. If you are an avid camper who wants to combine storage and shelter, this could be a good fit. For pure luggage carrying, a simpler roof box or bag is more practical.
- Combines a rooftop cargo carrier with a sleeping tent
- Made of 600D Oxford fabric with waterproof coating
- Includes a 2.5-inch foam mattress
Pros: Dual function: storage and camping shelter; Saves space compared to separate tent and carrier
Cons: Heavy and cumbersome to set up; Reduces fuel economy significantly
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best luggage carrier for an SUV?
The best luggage carrier depends on your needs. For a versatile, durable roof box, the Thule Motion XT L is our top pick. If you prefer a soft bag for occasional use, the Rightline Gear SUV Cargo Carrier offers great value. Hitch-mounted carriers like the Curt 18151 are ideal for heavy loads.
Can I use a luggage carrier with a sunroof?
Yes, but you need to ensure the carrier does not block the sunroof. Roof boxes and bags are designed to sit on crossbars, which typically do not interfere with sunroof operation. However, always check the clearance and your vehicle’s manual.
Will a luggage carrier affect my gas mileage?
Yes, any roof-mounted carrier increases wind resistance and reduces fuel economy. On average, expect a 10-20% decrease at highway speeds. Hitch-mounted carriers have less impact on aerodynamics but add weight. Soft bags may have a smaller effect than hard boxes.
How much weight can I put in a roof box?
Most roof boxes have a capacity of 100-165 lbs, but your vehicle’s roof rack also has a weight limit. Always check your owner’s manual for the dynamic load rating (when driving). Typically, it is around 100-165 lbs.
Do I need a roof rack to use a luggage carrier?
Most roof boxes and bags require crossbars or a roof rack system. Some soft bags can be mounted directly to the roof using straps that go through the door openings, but this may not be as secure. Hitch carriers require a trailer hitch receiver.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing the top luggage carriers for SUVs, we recommend the Thule Motion XT L as the best overall for its build quality, ease of use, and dual-side opening. For a more budget-friendly and versatile option, the Rightline Gear SUV Cargo Carrier is our runner-up, offering excellent value and storage for occasional trips.
