We researched and compared the top luggage carriers for cars, evaluating each on performance, durability, value, ease of use, and safety. Our analysis is based on manufacturer specifications, published safety standards, and aggregated owner feedback. Whether you need a hard-shell rooftop box or a soft cargo bag, this guide will help you choose the best option for your vehicle and travel style.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
Thule Motion XT L Best Overall Rooftop Box Capacity: 16 cubic feet, Weight: 46 lbs, Dimensions: 74.8 x 35.4 x 17.3 inches |
9.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite Runner Up Capacity: 16 cubic feet, Weight: 48 lbs, Dimensions: 81 x 34 x 17 inches |
8.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Rightline Gear Range 2 Car Top Carrier Best Soft Cargo Bag Capacity: 15 cubic feet, Weight: 13 lbs, Dimensions: 60 x 40 x 16 inches |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
SportRack Vista XL Rear Opening Cargo Box Best Budget Hard Shell Capacity: 11 cubic feet, Weight: 28 lbs, Dimensions: 62 x 32 x 16 inches |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Rola 59001 Roof Cargo Bag Best for No Roof Rack Capacity: 12.5 cubic feet, Weight: 8 lbs, Dimensions: 55 x 39 x 15 inches |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Malone Auto Vault 10.5 Compact Pick Capacity: 10.5 cubic feet, Weight: 32 lbs, Dimensions: 58 x 30 x 15 inches |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Car Mate 12311 Cargo Carrier Best Hitch-Mounted Carrier Capacity: 500 lbs, Weight: 42 lbs, Dimensions: 60 x 24 x 6 inches |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Thule Motion XT L: Best Overall Rooftop Box
The Thule Motion XT L is a top-tier rooftop cargo box that excels in performance and durability. Its sleek, aerodynamic shape minimizes wind noise, and the dual-side opening makes loading a breeze. The PowerClic mounting system is tool-free and secures the box firmly to your roof rack. Based on owner feedback, the box remains watertight even in heavy rain, and the glossy finish resists scratches.
However, the premium price is a significant investment. If you only need a carrier for occasional short trips, a soft cargo bag might be more cost-effective. Also, the box is heavy at 46 lbs, requiring two people for installation. Skip this if you have a small car with a low roof load limit.
- Aerodynamic design reduces wind noise and drag, improving fuel efficiency.
- Dual-side opening allows easy loading from either side of the vehicle.
- PowerClic mounting system provides quick, secure attachment to most roof racks.
Pros: Excellent build quality and weather resistance.; Spacious enough for skis and large suitcases.
Cons: Premium price point may not suit all budgets.
2. Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite: Runner Up
The Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite is a close competitor to the Thule Motion XT, offering similar capacity and a robust build. Its carbonite finish is UV-resistant, and the one-hand opening is convenient. The lid stays open securely, a feature appreciated by owners when loading heavy items. We found that the mounting system is straightforward, though it requires some initial adjustment.
One drawback is its weight; at 48 lbs, it is one of the heaviest boxes in its class. This can be a challenge for solo users. Also, the interior shape is not as wide as some competitors, limiting oversized items. If you need a box for frequent long trips and have a partner to help mount it, this is an excellent choice. But if you prioritize lightweight storage, consider a cargo bag instead.
- Slick carbonite finish resists fading and cracking from UV exposure.
- One-hand opening mechanism makes it easy to access cargo.
- Integrated lid stays open while loading, preventing accidental closure.
Pros: Very durable construction with a 10-year warranty.; Aerodynamic design reduces fuel consumption at highway speeds.
Cons: Heavy and bulky to store when not in use.
3. Rightline Gear Range 2 Car Top Carrier: Best Soft Cargo Bag
The Rightline Gear Range 2 is a popular soft cargo bag that offers excellent value for budget-conscious travelers. It is lightweight at 13 lbs and can be installed on most vehicles, even those without a roof rack, thanks to the included door-hook straps. The bag is made from durable PVC-coated polyester, and owner reviews generally praise its water resistance, though we note that heavy downpours can cause moisture ingress through the seams.
While the bag is easy to store and affordable, it has some limitations. It is not as secure as a hard shell, and items inside may shift during transit. The straps can also leave marks on door frames if not padded. This carrier is perfect for occasional road trips and soft luggage. However, if you frequently travel in rainy conditions or carry valuable electronics, we recommend a hard-shell box for better protection.
- Made from heavy-duty 600-denier PVC-coated polyester, water-resistant.
- Includes 4 reinforced tie-down straps with anti-slip buckles.
- Folds down compactly for easy storage when not in use.
Pros: Affordable and lightweight, easy to install and remove.; Works with most vehicles even without a roof rack (using included straps).
Cons: Not fully waterproof; seams may leak in heavy rain.; Less aerodynamic, causing some wind noise and potential drag.
4. SportRack Vista XL Rear Opening Cargo Box: Best Budget Hard Shell
The SportRack Vista XL is an entry-level hard-shell cargo box that provides a solid balance of cost and functionality. It is made from ABS plastic, which keeps the weight low at 28 lbs, making it easier to mount than heavier boxes. The rear opening is convenient for vehicles where side access is limited. Many owners appreciate the value for the price, noting that it keeps contents dry in moderate rain.
However, we found that the latch system can be inconsistent, with some users reporting difficulty closing it securely. The capacity is also on the smaller side, limiting its use for longer trips. If you have a small family and a tight budget, this box is a good starting point. But for those who need a larger, more reliable box, we suggest saving for a premium model.
- Rear opening design allows access from the back of the vehicle.
- ABS plastic construction is lightweight and impact-resistant.
- Includes a universal mounting system compatible with most roof racks.
Pros: Budget-friendly price for a hard-shell box.; Lightweight compared to premium boxes.
Cons: Smaller capacity may not fit larger families' luggage.; Latch mechanism can be finicky and may require force to close.
5. Rola 59001 Roof Cargo Bag: Best for No Roof Rack
The Rola 59001 is a no-frills cargo bag designed for vehicles without a roof rack. It relies on door-hook straps that are simple to install, though we caution that they can leave marks if the vehicle’s paint is delicate. The bag is made from water-resistant material, but based on owner feedback, it is not fully waterproof and can leak through the zipper in sustained rain.
This bag is best for short trips and dry weather. It is a great value for those who need occasional extra space without investing in a roof rack. However, if you frequently drive in rain or at high speeds, the bag’s aerodynamic drag and potential for shifting make it less ideal. We recommend this only for budget-conscious users who drive cautiously.
- Universal fit with no roof rack required; uses door hooks and straps.
- Made from heavy-duty 600 denier PVC-coated polyester, water-resistant.
- Includes a storage bag for compact folding when not in use.
Pros: Very affordable and lightweight, easy to install by one person.; Works on most vehicles including sedans and hatchbacks.
Cons: Not waterproof; owner reports of leaks in heavy rain.; Straps can scratch paint if not properly padded.
6. Malone Auto Vault 10.5: Compact Pick
The Malone Auto Vault 10.5 is a compact hard-shell box designed for smaller vehicles. Its HDPE construction is durable and UV-resistant, and the dual-side opening is a nice feature at this price point. Many owners find it easy to mount once the clamps are properly adjusted. The box is watertight and secure at highway speeds.
However, the capacity is limited to 10.5 cubic feet, which may not be enough for a family of four. Also, the mounting system uses a turn-knob design that some users find less intuitive than Thule’s PowerClic. This box is a good choice for couples or solo travelers with smaller cars. If you need more space, consider a larger model.
- Compact size ideal for smaller vehicles or limited roof space.
- Dual-side opening for convenient loading.
- Made from HDPE plastic, UV-stabilized to resist fading.
Pros: Good build quality for the price.; Fits well on compact cars and coupes.
Cons: Small capacity may not fit large suitcases or skis.; Mounting hardware can be tricky to adjust.
7. Car Mate 12311 Cargo Carrier: Best Hitch-Mounted Carrier
The Car Mate 12311 is a hitch-mounted cargo carrier that offers an alternative to roof boxes. It can hold up to 500 lbs, making it great for heavy gear. The carrier folds up when not in use, and the included waterproof bag keeps contents dry. Owners appreciate the ease of loading and unloading without climbing on the roof.
However, the carrier can obstruct the rear view and may require an extension for the license plate. It also adds length to the vehicle, making parking more challenging. This is best for those with a hitch receiver who need to transport bulky or heavy items. Skip it if you have a small car or need to access the trunk frequently.
- Hitch-mounted design frees up roof space and is easier to load.
- Folds up when not in use, allowing access to the rear hatch.
- Includes a waterproof cargo bag with tie-down loops.
Pros: High weight capacity, ideal for heavy items like coolers.; No need to lift items onto the roof.
Cons: Can block rear visibility and license plate.; Requires a 2-inch hitch receiver; not universal.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a hard-shell rooftop box and a soft cargo bag?
Hard-shell boxes offer superior protection from weather, security, and aerodynamics. They are more durable and reduce wind noise. Soft cargo bags are lighter, cheaper, and foldable for storage, but they are less secure and may leak in heavy rain. Your choice depends on your budget and how often you travel in adverse conditions.
Can I install a luggage carrier on a car without a roof rack?
Yes, soft cargo bags like the Rola 59001 and Rightline Gear Range 2 come with door-hook straps that work on most vehicles without a roof rack. However, you must ensure the straps do not damage the paint. Hard-shell boxes typically require a roof rack system.
How much weight can a rooftop cargo box hold?
Most rooftop boxes have a capacity of 50-75 lbs, but you must also consider your vehicle’s roof load limit (usually 100-165 lbs including the rack and box). Always check your owner’s manual. The box’s weight is part of the load, so subtract it from the limit.
Will a rooftop cargo box affect my fuel economy?
Yes, any roof-mounted carrier increases drag and reduces fuel economy, typically by 10-25% at highway speeds. Aerodynamic boxes like Thule Motion XT minimize this impact. Soft bags cause more drag. Removing the carrier when not in use helps save fuel.
How do I secure items inside a rooftop cargo box?
Use the built-in tie-down points or add a cargo net to prevent shifting. Distribute weight evenly and avoid overloading. For soft bags, pack tightly and use the provided straps to compress the load. Always double-check that the box is properly closed and locked before driving.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing the top luggage carriers for cars, we recommend the Thule Motion XT L as the best overall for its excellent build, aerodynamics, and ease of use. For a runner-up, the Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite offers similar quality with a slightly different design. If you are on a budget, the Rightline Gear Range 2 soft cargo bag provides great value for occasional use.
