After researching manufacturer specifications, safety standards, and hundreds of owner reviews, we compared the top carry all platforms for Category 1 and 2 three-point hitches. Our evaluation focuses on load capacity, build quality, ease of mounting, and real-world durability. Whether you need to haul firewood, hay bales, or construction materials, this guide will help you find the right carry all for your tractor.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
King Kutter Carry-All Best Overall 48 x 48 inch platform, 1500 lb capacity, Category 1 |
9.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Titan Attachments Carry All Best Value 48 x 40 inch platform, 1200 lb capacity, Category 1 |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
CountyLine Carry All Budget Pick 48 x 40 inch platform, 1000 lb capacity, Category 1 |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Walmart's Hyper Tough Carry All Light Duty 36 x 30 inch platform, 800 lb capacity, Category 1 |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Horizon Attachments Carry All Heavy Duty 60 x 48 inch platform, 2000 lb capacity, Category 2 |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
SpeeCo Carry All Versatile 48 x 40 inch platform, 1500 lb capacity, Category 1 |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Bush Hog Carry All Premium 48 x 48 inch platform, 2000 lb capacity, Category 1/2 |
9.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. King Kutter Carry-All: Best Overall
In our evaluation, the King Kutter Carry-All stands out for its robust construction and generous platform size. Owner feedback consistently praises its ability to handle up to 1500 pounds of firewood or hay without flexing. The powder coat finish resists rust better than many painted alternatives, and the included safety chains meet industry standards for secure towing.
However, the smooth steel platform offers little traction when wet, which can cause loads to shift. This carry all is best for those who need a reliable, no-fuss platform for occasional heavy hauling. It may not be ideal for frequent use on wet or muddy terrain unless you add a non-slip mat.
- Heavy-duty welded steel frame with powder coat finish
- Large 48×48 inch platform for bulky loads
- Includes safety chains and mounting hardware
Pros: Excellent build quality for heavy loads; Easy to attach and detach from hitch
Cons: Platform can be slippery when wet
2. Titan Attachments Carry All: Best Value
Based on owner feedback and the spec sheet, the Titan Attachments Carry All offers a solid balance of capacity and affordability. The 48×40 inch platform with removable side panels makes it versatile for both bulk and loose loads. Many users report satisfaction with its performance for moving dirt, gravel, or firewood.
However, some owners noted weld quality variations, with a few units having minor porosity. This carry all is a smart choice for budget-conscious buyers who don’t need the highest capacity. Skip it if you require a perfectly finished product or plan to haul near the 1200-pound limit frequently.
- Strong steel frame with black powder coat
- Removable side panels for versatility
- Compatible with most Category 1 tractors
Pros: Great value for the price; Side panels keep smaller items secure
Cons: Welds can be inconsistent on some units
3. CountyLine Carry All: Budget Pick
In our comparison, the CountyLine Carry All is a basic, no-frills platform that gets the job done for light tasks. It has a 1000-pound capacity and a 48×40 inch platform, which is sufficient for moving small loads of brush or garden waste. The bolt-together construction is straightforward, and many owners appreciate the low investment.
However, the thinner steel and lighter welds mean it is not built for abuse. Several reviews mention bending when overloaded or used on uneven ground. This carry all is best for homeowners with small tractors who need an occasional helper. Avoid it if you plan to haul heavy materials like rocks or wet soil regularly.
- Affordable price point for light-duty use
- Simple bolt-on assembly
- Lightweight design for easy handling
Pros: Low cost entry for occasional users; Easy to assemble and mount
Cons: Not suitable for heavy loads or rough terrain
4. Walmart's Hyper Tough Carry All: Light Duty
Researching owner feedback, the Hyper Tough Carry All is a compact, lightweight option for small subcompact tractors. Its 36×30 inch platform and 800-pound capacity are adequate for light chores like moving potting soil or firewood kindling. The low weight makes it easy to mount and store.
But the small size and lighter construction mean it is not a heavy hauler. Some users reported the paint chipping quickly and the platform flexing under moderate loads. This carry all is best for those with limited storage space and very light needs. Skip it if you have a full-size tractor or need to move heavy materials.
- Compact size for small tractors
- Lightweight at only 45 pounds
- Easy to store when not in use
Pros: Very affordable and easy to handle; Good for small loads like bags of mulch
Cons: Small platform limits use; Not built for heavy or frequent use
5. Horizon Attachments Carry All: Heavy Duty
In our evaluation, the Horizon Attachments Carry All is a beast built for serious work. With a 60×48 inch platform and 2000-pound capacity, it can handle large bales, pallets, or construction materials. The reinforced frame and stake pockets allow for custom side panels, making it adaptable for various tasks. Owner feedback highlights its durability even under continuous heavy use.
However, its size and weight require a Category 2 hitch and a powerful tractor. It is also cumbersome to mount without assistance. This carry all is best for farmers or contractors with large tractors who need maximum capacity. Skip it if you have a Category 1 tractor or limited storage, as it will be oversized.
- Extra-large platform for oversized loads
- Reinforced frame with heavy gauge steel
- Includes stake pockets for side extensions
Pros: Massive capacity for large tractors; Stake pockets add versatility
Cons: Requires Category 2 hitch or adapter; Very heavy; difficult to handle alone
6. SpeeCo Carry All: Versatile
Based on manufacturer specs and owner reviews, the SpeeCo Carry All offers a unique folding side design that allows it to function as both a flatbed and a box. This versatility is appreciated by users who switch between hauling loose materials and large items. The integrated tie-down slots meet safety standards for securing loads.
However, some owners reported that the folding side latches can loosen after extended use, requiring occasional tightening. This carry all is ideal for those who need a multi-purpose platform for varied tasks. It may not be the best choice if you only haul flat, bulky items and prefer a simpler, more robust fixed design.
- Folding sides for easy conversion to flatbed
- Built-in tie-down slots
- Quick-attach design for Category 1
Pros: Folding sides add flexibility; Tie-down slots secure loads
Cons: Latch mechanism can wear over time
7. Bush Hog Carry All: Premium
In our comparison, the Bush Hog Carry All is the premium option, built to withstand the toughest conditions. The diamond plate platform offers superior grip, and the 2000-pound capacity handles heavy loads without flex. Owner feedback consistently mentions its longevity and resistance to rust, even in harsh environments. The dual-hitch compatibility adds flexibility for different tractors.
However, this quality comes at a premium price, making it a significant investment. It is best for professional users or serious hobbyists who demand the best and plan to use the carry all extensively. Skip it if you are on a tight budget or only need occasional light hauling, as the cost may not be justified.
- Top-tier construction with heavy-duty steel
- Large 48×48 inch platform with diamond plate
- Compatible with both Category 1 and 2 hitches
Pros: Exceptional build quality and durability; Diamond plate provides excellent traction
Cons: High price point
Frequently Asked Questions
What size carry all do I need for my tractor?
Choose a carry all that matches your tractor’s hitch category (Category 1 or 2) and horsepower. For most compact tractors (20-50 HP), a 48×40 inch platform with 1000-1500 lb capacity works well. Larger tractors (50+ HP) can handle bigger platforms up to 60×48 inches and 2000 lb capacity. Always check your tractor’s lift capacity to avoid overloading.
Can I use a carry all on a three-point hitch with a quick hitch?
Yes, many carry alls are compatible with quick hitches, but you may need to adjust the top link or use a bushing kit. Some models have a fixed top link bracket that may not align with all quick hitches. Check the product specifications or owner reviews for compatibility before purchasing.
How do I secure loads on a carry all?
Use ratchet straps or ropes through tie-down slots or around the platform edges. Some carry alls come with stake pockets or side panels that help contain smaller items. For safety, always secure loads to prevent shifting during transport, especially on uneven terrain.
Are carry alls safe for road use?
Carry alls are designed for off-road or farm use, not for highway travel. If you must move a carry all on public roads, ensure the load is secured, use safety chains, and obey local speed limits. Some states require a slow-moving vehicle sign. Check your local regulations.
How do I maintain my carry all to prevent rust?
After each use, clean off mud and debris. Store the carry all in a dry place or cover it. Touch up any chipped paint with rust-inhibiting paint. Models with powder coat or galvanized finishes resist rust better than painted ones. Regular inspection of welds and bolts is recommended.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing, the King Kutter Carry-All earns our top pick for its excellent balance of capacity, build quality, and value. For those who need maximum durability and premium features, the Bush Hog Carry-All is a standout runner-up, offering exceptional traction and longevity.
Last reviewed and spec-checked: April 7, 2026. We re-check our picks and listings periodically.
