Whether you’re heading on a family road trip or need extra gear for camping, a cargo carrier can significantly expand your vehicle’s storage. We researched and compared dozens of models, evaluating manufacturer specifications, safety standards, and aggregated owner feedback. Our guide covers roof baskets, hard shells, soft bags, and hitch-mounted platforms to help you choose the right carrier for your needs and vehicle.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
Thule Motion XT XL Best Overall Hard Shell Capacity: 16 cu ft, Load limit: 165 lbs, Weight: 48 lbs |
9.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite Best Value Hard Shell Capacity: 16 cu ft, Load limit: 165 lbs, Weight: 47 lbs |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Rightline Gear Range 2 Best Soft Roof Bag Capacity: 15 cu ft, Load limit: 100 lbs, Weight: 10 lbs |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Curt 18112 Roof Cargo Basket Best Roof Basket Capacity: 11 cu ft, Load limit: 150 lbs, Weight: 35 lbs |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
MaxxHaul 70115 Hitch Mount Cargo Carrier Best Hitch Carrier Capacity: 500 lbs, Platform size: 60 x 20 inches, Weight: 42 lbs |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
SERAPRIL Car Top Carrier Roof Bag Budget Soft Bag Capacity: 15 cu ft, Load limit: 110 lbs, Weight: 8 lbs |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Rola 59005 Roof Cargo Basket Compact Roof Basket Capacity: 7 cu ft, Load limit: 100 lbs, Weight: 28 lbs |
7.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Thule Motion XT XL: Best Overall Hard Shell
The Thule Motion XT XL stands out in our evaluation for its premium construction and thoughtful features. Based on owner feedback and the spec sheets, the dual-side opening and Power-Click mounting system make installation and access effortless. The aerodynamic shape minimizes wind noise, a common complaint with boxier carriers.
However, this carrier is a significant investment. If you only need occasional cargo space or have a tight budget, consider a soft-sided bag or a more affordable hard shell. It is best for frequent travelers who prioritize durability and convenience.
- Dual-side opening for easy access from either side of the vehicle.
- Power-Click mounting system with torque indicator ensures secure fit.
- Aerodynamic design reduces wind noise and drag, improving fuel economy.
Pros: Excellent build quality and weather sealing.; Integrated lid stays open without support.
Cons: High price point may not suit all budgets.
2. Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite: Best Value Hard Shell
The Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite offers a great balance of price and performance. We compared its specs against similarly priced models and found its locking system and dual-side opening to be standout features. Owner feedback highlights its ease of installation and reliable weather resistance.
Some users report that the latches require extra effort in freezing temperatures. If you live in a cold climate, you might prefer the Thule Motion XT’s more robust mechanism. This carrier is ideal for those wanting a secure, durable hard shell without the premium price.
- Dual-side opening with gas-assisted struts for smooth operation.
- HitchLock and SKS locking system for security.
- Fits most vehicles with factory or aftermarket crossbars.
Pros: Competitive price for a hard shell with excellent security features.; Sleek design with low profile.
Cons: Latching mechanism can be finicky in cold weather.
3. Rightline Gear Range 2: Best Soft Roof Bag
The Rightline Gear Range 2 is a top pick among soft roof bags according to owner feedback. We researched its construction and found the welded seams and heavy-duty PVC offer excellent waterproofing. It is easy to install and remove, and it stores compactly.
However, it is not for heavy items or high-speed travel. The 100 lb limit and potential wind noise may deter some. If you need to carry bulky, heavy gear or drive frequently at highway speeds, a hard shell is a better choice.
- Waterproof PVC-coated fabric with welded seams.
- Universal fit with vehicle-specific anchor straps.
- Easy fold-down storage when not in use.
Pros: Very affordable and lightweight.; Can be used on vehicles without roof racks (with included straps).
Cons: Lower load capacity compared to hard shells.; Potential for flapping at highway speeds if not secured tightly.
4. Curt 18112 Roof Cargo Basket: Best Roof Basket
The Curt 18112 is a solid roof basket that we evaluated for its build quality and expandable design. Owner feedback praises its ability to carry awkward items like coolers and camping gear. The included wind fairing helps with noise reduction.
However, it lacks a cover, so your gear is vulnerable to rain and theft. You will need a separate cargo net or waterproof bag. If you need a secure, weatherproof solution, consider a hard shell carrier instead.
- Steel construction with black powder coat finish.
- Expanding design (46 x 39 x 6 inches) fits various roof sizes.
- Includes wind fairing to reduce drag and noise.
Pros: Rugged and durable for odd-shaped items.; Expandable width for versatility.
Cons: No cover; items exposed to weather and theft.; Installation can be time-consuming.
5. MaxxHaul 70115 Hitch Mount Cargo Carrier: Best Hitch Carrier
The MaxxHaul 70115 is a popular hitch-mounted carrier based on owner feedback. We compared its specs and found it offers the highest load capacity in our guide at 500 lbs. The steel construction is sturdy, and the anti-rattle bolt reduces wobble.
However, it can obstruct your tailgate and rear lights. You may need a hitch extension or a light bar accessory. This carrier is best for those with a hitch receiver who need to haul heavy items like coolers or camping gear, but not for those who frequently access their trunk.
- Fits 2-inch receiver hitch, includes anti-rattle bolt.
- Folded steel platform with raised edges to prevent cargo shifting.
- Reflective tape for increased visibility.
Pros: Very high weight capacity.; Easy to install and remove.
Cons: Can block rear access and license plate.; May reduce departure angle on steep driveways.
6. SERAPRIL Car Top Carrier Roof Bag: Budget Soft Bag
The SERAPRIL roof bag is an entry-level option that we included for budget-conscious buyers. Owner feedback indicates it works well for occasional use and light loads. The triple-layer fabric offers decent water resistance for the price.
However, some users report seam separation after a few trips. It is not suitable for frequent or heavy-duty use. If you plan to use a cargo carrier regularly or carry valuable items, invest in a higher-quality bag or a hard shell.
- Triple-layer fabric with waterproof coating.
- Universal fit with 8 reinforced tie-down straps.
- Reflective strips for nighttime safety.
Pros: Very low price point.; Lightweight and easy to store.
Cons: Durability concerns with long-term use.; May leak in heavy rain if not properly sealed.
7. Rola 59005 Roof Cargo Basket: Compact Roof Basket
The Rola 59005 is a compact roof basket designed for smaller vehicles. We researched its dimensions and found it fits well on cars with short roofs. Owner feedback highlights its solid build but notes the lack of a wind fairing leads to noticeable noise.
Its small capacity (7 cu ft) limits what you can carry. If you need to transport bulky items or have a larger vehicle, consider a bigger basket or a hard shell. This carrier is best for solo travelers or couples with minimal gear.
- Compact size fits vehicles with limited roof space.
- Black powder-coated steel with corrosion resistance.
- Includes universal mounting hardware for most crossbars.
Pros: Small footprint suitable for compact cars.; Sturdy construction for its size.
Cons: Limited capacity not ideal for large families.; No wind fairing; can be noisy at highway speeds.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a hard shell and a soft roof bag?
Hard shell carriers are rigid, lockable, and offer better weather protection, aerodynamics, and security. Soft bags are lighter, cheaper, and fold away when not in use, but they have lower load capacities and may leak or flap at high speeds. Choose a hard shell for frequent use and security; choose a soft bag for occasional, light-duty trips.
Can I use a roof cargo carrier with a sunroof?
Yes, but you must ensure the carrier does not obstruct the sunroof opening. Most roof carriers mount on crossbars that sit above the roof, allowing the sunroof to function. However, check the carrier’s height and your vehicle’s roof clearance to avoid interference.
How do I determine the right size cargo carrier for my vehicle?
Measure your vehicle’s roof length and width between the crossbars. Also check your roof weight limit (often 100-165 lbs for factory racks). Choose a carrier that fits within those dimensions and does not exceed the dynamic load rating. For hitch carriers, ensure your hitch has sufficient tongue weight capacity.
Are hitch cargo carriers safe for highway driving?
Yes, when properly installed and loaded. Ensure the carrier is securely attached with anti-rattle bolts and that the load is evenly distributed and tied down. Avoid exceeding the hitch’s weight rating. Some carriers include reflective tape for visibility. Check local laws regarding license plate obstruction; you may need a light bar or license plate relocation kit.
How much weight can a typical roof cargo carrier hold?
Most roof carriers have a load limit between 100 and 165 lbs, including the weight of the carrier itself. This limit is set by the vehicle manufacturer and the carrier’s design. Always check your vehicle’s roof load capacity in the owner’s manual and do not exceed it.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing the top car cargo carriers, our top pick is the Thule Motion XT XL for its superior build quality, ease of use, and aerodynamic design. For a more budget-friendly hard shell, the Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite is a close runner-up, offering great value and security.
